Stacy Koltiska didn’t expect quitting her job as a school lunch lady would make international news a year ago.

She didn’t know that when she wrote about her experience on Facebook her post would go viral, or that she would do dozens of interviews and receive dozens of messages from educators across the globe.

“I just followed my heart and my conscience,” said Ms. Koltiska, of North Strabane. “I’m not going to make a little boy cry.”

Almost 12 months to the day after it made national headlines when Ms. Koltiska said she was forced to swap a 6-year-old’s hot lunch for a plain cheese sandwich, the Canon-McMillan School District has become one of the first in Pennsylvania to switch its policy into compliance with new state legislation banning so-called “lunch shaming.”

Advertise with us

Some school districts across the country have come under fire recently for “unintentionally stigmatizing” students who don’t have enough money in their cafeteria accounts to cover the cost of the hot meal and instead are offered an alternative such as a cold sandwich. That’s what happened that day last September when Ms. Koltiska, then a cafeteria worker at Wylandville Elementary School, said she was forced to take back a boy’s chicken nuggets, throw them away and exchange them for a sandwich.

“To see his little face when he saw that cheese … I just couldn’t believe it,” said Ms. Koltiska, who quit her job in protest. “I don’t care who gets credit for what. I’m just glad no child is going to go through that again.”

Under the new district policy, which the Canon-McMillan board passed in August, school leaders will ramp up their efforts to communicate with parents directly about low or overdue balances and make it easier for them to manage the accounts. No longer will students be offered an alternative meal, superintendent Michael Daniels said.

“No matter the ability to pay, every single student entering our cafeterias will be offered a hot lunch with no questions asked,” he said.

The original policy was put in place last year because of federal and state laws that require school districts to establish guidelines for collecting money owed on student lunch accounts.

Advertise with us

“While our policy followed those state and national standards, they really focused too much on the dollars and the cents, and not common sense,” Mr. Daniels said. “We want to get beyond that. It’s not OK for that to be the case.”

The “unintentional consequences” of such policies, such as embarrassing a child by taking back his or her lunch or not serving them lunch at all, prompted legislation at the state level that lawmakers hope will mitigate those in the future. If passed, schools will be prohibited from publicly identifying students with negative accounts, revoking their meals or making them do chores to pay off the debt.

“Our children are our most valuable resource and we must treat them as such and show respect for families at home supporting them,” state. Sen. Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills, said in a news release. “I am hopeful that more school districts will do the right thing and follow Canon-McMillan’s lead.”

While the requirements of law don’t affect districts that qualify to provide free meals to all students, including Pittsburgh Public Schools and the Sto-Rox School District, others have instituted policies that allow them to keep up with the money owed without embarrassing the children.

“We never deny kids a lunch,” said Sarah Welch, spokeswoman for the Keystone Oaks School District. “They are prohibited from buying any extras — ice cream, bags of chips, things along those lines — but they still get their full lunch when their account is in the negative.”

Advertise with us

The district informs parents and guardians via text or phone call when the account balance gets low, Ms. Welch said. When the debt reaches $30, the district sends a certified letter in the mail.

The Carlynton School District offers an “emergency meal” consisting of a sandwich, fruit, vegetable and milk if the student’s account reaches a a certain negative balance, said Michelle Weaver, the district’s national school lunch coordinator. A cafeteria worker would never take a meal back from a student, and the district frequently works with parents who need help paying by setting up payment plans or helping them apply for the free or reduced lunch program for their student.

“Our parents are pretty on top of it,” Ms. Weaver said. “We’ve never had any complaints from parents about a child having to have an alternate meal or anything like that. Our cashiers aren’t supposed to confront the children.”

The Quaker Valley School District also sends parents automated messages about low account balances, spokeswoman Angela Conigliaro said. No matter their balance, every student receives the same meal, and cafeteria staff members never discuss it with the students themselves.

“No one wants to put a student in the spotlight for something that is an adult’s responsibility,” she said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Koltiska, who has three children enrolled in Canon-McMillan schools, said she has received an outpouring support for what she did to raise awareness of the issue of “lunch shaming. Mr. Daniels said the Canon-McMillan district received more than $1,000 in unsolicited donations from people who wanted to help pay some student lunch debts.

This shouldn’t even be a choice,” Ms. Koltiska said. “All states should not be able to do this to children. This is a good start, but it will be good when everybody is treated the same.”

Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1590.