Pittsburgh City Council weighed in on the labor dispute between The Ellis School and its former custodial workers, urging in a letter that the private school hire back seven people who lost their jobs as a result of a new contract.
A letter signed by all nine council members was left with the school administration Monday, criticizing the Shadyside landmark’s decision to hire a custodial company that pays “poverty wages” that are lower than its predecessor’s rates.
Council said it’s proud of “family-sustaining working conditions through cooperation between workers, building owners and cleaning contractors.” But “The Ellis School is undermining those standards by employing a cleaning contractor that intends to pay its employees as little as $8.68 per hour without access to healthcare,” the letter reads.
Union activists later revised the estimated minimum to $7.75 an hour, citing a pay stub.
Council members Natalia Rudiak and Deborah Gross delivered the letter about midday. Ms. Rudiak said they tried to meet with Macon Finley and Deborah Kuchta, the head of school and the finance director, respectively. Another director reported that Ms. Finley was out and Ms. Kuchta unavailable, Ms. Rudiak said.
She said the council members left without any commitment for a future meeting.
“These folks [cleaning workers] are making less than $200 a week after taxes, which is surreal for a school that claims to teach the next generation to fight for what is just,” Ms. Rudiak said.
The Service Employees International Union 32BJ, which represents the former employees from Alder Services, filed a complaint with the National Labor Relations Board on Aug. 8, claiming that the all-girls preparatory school refused to rehire the custodial workers because of their union membership.
But SEIU has withdrawn that challenge, Ms. Finley said in a statement to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. She said United Steelworkers is representing cleaners with the new contractor, Homestead-based General Cleaning. USW and General did not immediately return calls Monday.
General took over the contract Aug. 1 with workers who are paid around $5 less an hour than the former staff from Alder, union officials said. Ms. Finley said the school ended its relationship with Alder “in strict accordance with the applicable terms of the contract.”
“Notably, that cleaning company has not challenged our right to have changed cleaning companies,” she said. “Second, our reasons for doing so were legitimate non-economic reasons -— based solely on our goal of having a healthy, safe, clean learning environment for our students, and not based on cost -— that we discussed in detail with that company before making the decision.”
SEIU confirmed withdrawing an NLRB complaint. Displaced workers weren’t available on a short timeframe to provide testimony in the matter, said Sam Williamson, an area leader for the union. He said he expects the complaint will be refiled.
In a letter to parents last month, Ms. Finley said the school had several concerns about Alder, including a lack of the required clearances for the employees to work at a school; a fight between workers who ultimately had to be removed from the property; a report of an incident during a sports practice that made a student “uncomfortable;” a management change at the company; and notification that its insurance had lapsed due to non-payment.
Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1590. Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.