BELLEFONTE, Pa. — In a stunning decision, a Centre County district judge on Friday threw out involuntary manslaughter and aggravated assault charges against eight members of a Penn State fraternity in the death of sophomore pledge Tim Piazza, ordering 14 of the frat brothers to stand trial on lesser counts.
In dismissing those charges, including aggravated assault which is a felony, District Judge Allen Sinclair let stand lesser charges including hazing and furnishing alcohol to minors.
The ruling culminates a preliminary hearing that has been anything but ordinary, both in its length and its use by defense attorneys as a trial test.
Centre County District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller said she planned to seek a county judge’s permission to refile the involuntary manslaughter charges, and might also attempt to reinstate the aggravated assault charges.
Ms. Parks Miller, who vigorously argued the case and maintained throughout that the men shared culpability in Mr. Piazza’s death, said she believes the judge ruled based on an assessment of the defendants’ individual roles, which she called “a huge legal error” in a case she pursued based on a theory of accomplice liability. Sinclair declined to comment about the case after he ruled.
“Sometimes judges get it wrong — that’s why we have an appeal,” she said.
Read More
Defense attorneys said they would challenge any effort to restore the dismissed charges, and will work to whittle down what remains.
Leonard Ambrose, lawyer for fraternity member Joseph Sala, 19, said there was “no basis for most of the charges.”
“She can refile, but obviously we’re going to contest any refiling,” he said. “She had seven days to make her case.”
Mr. Piazza’s parents, Jim and Evelyn, of Lebanon, N.J., who sat in the front row for the proceedings, declined to comment on the judge’s ruling as they left the courthouse.
Ms. Parks Miller said the couple was “shocked” by the decision.
But the decision brought relief to parents and fraternity members whose futures hung in the balance.
Judge Sinclair’s decision followed seven days of testimony and arguments from attorneys for 16 of the 18 men charged in Mr. Piazza’s death following a booze-soaked pledge night party where hazing is alleged.
Students who will stand trial on at least one charge include: Brendan Young, 21, of Malvern, president of the now defunct Beta Theta Pi chapter at Penn State, and fellow fraternity members Daniel Casey, 20, of Ronkonkoma, N.Y, the pledge master; Jonah Neuman, 20, of Nashville; Nick Kubera, 19, of Downingtown, Pa.; Michael Bonatucci, 20, of Woodstock, Ga.; Gary DiBileo, 21, of Scranton; Luke Visser, 19, of Encinitas, Calif.; and Joe Sala, 19, of Erie.

In all, 14 of 18 fraternity members originally arrested in the case will stand trial on a least one charge.
Mr. Piazza, prosecutors allege, was forced to consume large amounts of alcohol during a Feb. 2 hazing ritual, known as a drinking “gauntlet” and later fell down the basement stairs. Prosecutors obtained video from the now-defunct fraternity house, which showed Mr. Piazza falling several other times. Fraternity members left him to languish on a couch and didn’t call for emergency help until almost 12 hours later.
Mr. Piazza died Feb. 4 of a head injury, ruptured spleen and collapsed lung.
Prosecutors argued that each fraternity member charged played a role in the death or tried to cover it up afterward.
In an unusual twist, prosecutors showed clips from a video taken from the fraternity house that showed pledges including Mr. Piazza running from drinking station to drinking station, guzzling booze, and captured gruesome footage of a severely impaired Mr. Piazza, alone in the wee hours of the morning, struggling and falling on the floor.
Security camera footage captured Mr. Piazza, a sophomore engineering student, falling several times during the night of drinking, and an autopsy indicated he had consumed a dangerous amount of alcohol. Cameras inside the house recorded the response of fraternity leaders and other members as they dealt with the injured and intoxicated student with a series of ineffectual and even counterproductive efforts.
Excerpts from the footage, narrated by the lead detective during a previous court session, showed fraternity members holding down Mr. Piazza, strapping him to a loaded backpack to keep him from turning over and choking, pouring liquids on him and trying to get him to stand so they could dress him, even though he appeared to be unconscious.
Defense attorneys sought to minimize their clients’ role and asserted that the fraternity members couldn’t have known that Mr. Piazza’s life was in danger. They also tried to divert attention to Tim Bream, the 56-year-old Penn State athletic trainer who served as live-in adviser to the fraternity but was not charged with a crime.

They argued the students had little reason to anticipate tragic results from a night that also included an alcohol-fueled social mixer with a sorority group.
“Yes, there’s excessive drinking on college campuses,” defense attorney Theodore Simon said Thursday. “That does not transform it into criminal behavior.”
Prosecutors, in turn, disputed a suggestion that defendants would not have known of the danger because no one had died during the fraternity chapter’s long history.
“As far as this idea, ‘Well, nobody died before,‘ do they really think they get a free death before someone is held responsible?” Ms. Parks Miller told the judge during Thursday’s hearing.
The Associated Press contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.