Poor cleaning, physical fights between employees and a situation that left one student “uncomfortable” were among the reasons The Ellis School in Shadyside cited for not renewing the contract for its former cleaning services company.
The decision to award a contract to a different company had nothing to do with finances, the head of the all-girls preparatory school said in a letter to parents Monday evening.
“The Ellis School not only has the legal right to make decisions on which cleaning services it chooses, but the School has an obligation to make decisions based first and foremost on the welfare of our students,” Macon Finley wrote.
The letter was sent following a protest outside the school Monday morning, in which the seven former custodial workers at the school — all employees of Alder Services of Pittsburgh — and dozens of union members demanded their jobs back.
In the letter, Ms. Macon said in addition to “many examples of poor cleaning,” the school had several concerns about Alder, including a lack of the required clearances for the employees to work at a school; a fight between workers who ultimately had to be removed from the property; report of an incident during a sports practice that made a student “uncomfortable;” a management change at the company; and notification that its insurance had lapsed due to non-payment.
The Service Employees International Union 32BJ, which represents the Alder Services employees, filed a complaint with the National Labor Relations Board on Aug. 8, claiming that the school refused to rehire the custodial workers because of their union membership. The complaint also accused the new contractor, Homestead-based General Cleaning, with “recognizing another union and entering into a collective bargaining agreement with such union to cover the cleaners without any demonstration of majority support by the cleaners for the union.”
General Cleaning took over the contract Aug. 1 with new workers who are represented by the United Steel Workers and are paid $4 less an hour than the former staff from Alder, union officials said.
In the letter to parents, Ms. Finley said even though it is not “typical practice to discuss the details of private decisions we make and are entitled to make,” she wanted to make some clarifications after parents inquired about the situation. She could not immediately be reached for comment.
The cleaning workers were employees of a contractor, not the school, so school leaders never had any control over their wages or employment status, she wrote. The new contractor employs the same number of employees as the former, and additionally, the school has no control over their union status.
“Before deciding to make a change in cleaning services, we had many discussions with the former cleaning service about our concerns,” Ms. Finley said. “Our hope was that by working together constructively, they would resolve the issues and we could continue our arrangement.”
Sam Williamson, the SEIU’s district leader for Western Pennsylvania, said the union’s primary concern was that until Tuesday, the former cleaners had not been allowed to reapply for their jobs with the new cleaning contractor.
The lower wages offered by General Cleaning are also “inappropriate” at a school like Ellis, he said.
“The workers themselves were not given any notice that their jobs were in jeopardy or that there were concerns about their job performance,” Mr. Williamson said.
Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1590.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.