As it pondered another tuition increase, the board overseeing Pennsylvania’s 14 state-owned universities found itself in a familiar but uncomfortable place Thursday, just a day after a consultant warned the status-quo must change.

Board member after board member lamented the idea of further burdening tens of thousands of students across a system where enrollment already has fallen. Yet they voted to do it anyway, saying their cash-starved universities could not afford to fill a $72 million budget gap exclusively with a new round of budget cuts.

With their state near last in subsidies for higher education, some on the board of governors characterized Thursday’s 3.5 percent, or $254 yearly, increase in the base tuition for 2017-18 as simply being realistic.

"We can't expect a truck to be backed up with enough money from the state to solve all our problems," said board member Thomas Muller, the Lehigh County executive.

Advertise with us

But while the vote was unanimous, it sparked familiar criticism in a board room that seemed to harbor leftover tension from a consultant’s blunt assessment Wednesday of the system’s enrollment and financial predicament and the varied causes, including what it said was flawed governance.

In comments to the board, the head of the faculty union reiterated the charge that students are being priced out of system universities that by state law are supposed to ensure an affordable education.

"... A 3.5 percent increase in tuition and corresponding fees — plus whatever increases are passed on campus — does make a difference to the lives of working families," Kenneth Mash, president of the Association of Pennsylvania State College and University Faculties, said in prepared remarks. "It is not an increase in isolation; it is an increase that builds on consecutive increases."

A faculty union leader from Kutztown University spoke of a lack of mutual respect. Waving a collective bargaining agreement in her hand, she said labor wanted an equal place at the table in deciding the system’s response to recommendations for change by the consultant, the National Center for Higher Education Management Systems.

State System Chancellor Frank Brogan, at one point banging the table in front of him for emphasis, said bargaining from opposite sides of the table is not working together. “Nobody up here disrespects anybody in this system,” he said.

Advertise with us

“If there is somebody around the table who is happy about raising tuition, would you please raise your hand and announce yourself?” he said. “If there’s anybody around this table — or by the way this room — (who) has a perfect answer to the issue of tuition, would you please go to that podium and save us all a lot of time today?”

About half the $72 million gap will be closed by campus cuts, system officials said. They said their schools still are the least expensive public university option in the state, thousands less than the University of Pittsburgh or Penn State University.

Thursday’s vote means the base yearly rate for in-state undergraduates will be $7,492. But some schools have replaced that flat full-time rate for 12 to 18 credits a semester with per-credit pricing, meaning students on those campuses in many cases will pay more.

The board also put the technology fee at $464 for full-time resident students and $706 for full-time nonresidents. Pitt and Penn State are expected to set their tuitions next week.

Also Thursday, Sen. Andy Dinniman, D-Chester, minority chairman of the Senate Education Committee, said his panel will review the consultant’s report. He praised the NCHEMS proposal for a statewide coordinating body for higher education, calling it overdue, but was unclear about the call to replace the system’s board of governors with a board of regents.

Advertise with us

In general, he said, the consultant’s presentation “didn’t tell us anything we didn’t know.”

He said state government shares blame, both for its funding level for higher education and for “not insisting that there be better coordination” among the State System and other schools.

The State System includes Bloomsburg, California, Cheyney, Clarion, East Stroudsburg, Edinboro, Indiana, Kutztown, Lock Haven, Mansfield, Millersville, Shippensburg, Slippery Rock and West Chester universities.

Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @BschacknerPG.