The state’s auditor general scolded Penn State University on Thursday for “whopping” tuition increases, accepting out-of-state students on its main campus at rates eclipsing those for Pennsylvanians, and for insufficient screening of employees working with youth.

Eugene DePasquale, releasing results of the first-ever performance audit of the state’s largest university, said Penn State has made progress on reforms since the Jerry Sandusky child sex abuse scandal rocked the campus in 2011.

Nevertheless, he said the university must further improve governance practices and standards for transparency and safety. He said the General Assembly needs to reduce Penn State’s 38-member trustees board — and those of Pennsylvania’s other state-related universities — and bring Penn State under the state’s Right-to-Know Law, from which it now is largely exempt.

Penn State receives tens of millions of taxpayer dollars annually, and as such, has an obligation to avoid pricing middle-class Pennsylvanians out of classroom seats, Mr DePasquale said. He also said Pennsylvanians should be the top priority in filling those seats.

Advertise with us

But that’s not what is happening, he said, at the priciest public research university among Big Ten schools, one of the costliest in the nation for in-state students.

“Over the past 30 years, Penn State’s in-state tuition — at $19,347 for the 2016-17 academic year — has increased by a whopping 535 percent,” Mr. DePasquale said. “With the exception of 2015-16, resident tuition increased every year — on average about 6.4 percent.”

Penn State officials, in response, said they work hard to curb rising costs in a state ranked near the bottom in funding higher education, and they denied any out-of-state preference. They cited numerous safety-related improvements and suggested Mr. DePasquale’s findings on worker background checks were not fully fact-based.

“The safety of students, faculty and staff has been, and continues to be, a top priority,” a university statement read.

Mr. DePasquale said it is “troubling” that “nonresident students have been accepted at higher rates than Pennsylvania residents at University Park, PSU’s primary and most desirable campus.”

Advertise with us

Back in 1990-91, 77 percent of students at University Park were Pennsylvanians. As of 2016-17, that figure had declined to 55 percent, according to the university’s website.

He noted that Penn State is insistent that it never intentionally accepts nonresidents over in-state students “and we found no evidence to suggest otherwise.” Still, Mr. DePasquale cautioned that such practices are occurring at other similar universities.

“While not a strategic decision by the university, this trend could make sound business sense because to attend PSU’s Main Campus (University Park), nonresidents pay tuition of $34,183, compared to residents who pay $19,347,” Mr. DePasquale wrote. “In essence, nonresidents help to subsidize the cost of resident tuition.”

The audit, begun in August 2016, yielded a 115-page report covering January 2013 through March of this year. Speaking at a Harrisburg news conference, Mr. DePasquale outlined its nine findings and 23 recommendations for improving operations.

The audit found that Penn State fails to ensure all workers coming in contact with children through university-operated youth camps have required background checks, even five years after reforms announced in the wake of the Sandusky child sexual abuse scandal.

Advertise with us

Sandusky, a former Penn State assistant football coach who operated a charity that held youth camps on campus and in conjunction with the university, is serving 30 to 60 years for sexually abusing children.

Mr. DePasquale said as many as 57 youth camps held during 2016 may have operated with one or more staffers not having the background clearances required by law. His auditors found 7.9 percent of the youth camps they examined had at least one clearance missing for at least one staffer associated with the camp.

Penn State held 732 such camps in 2016; auditors examined the records for 76 of them.

“This error rate is poor for any university, but for PSU, it is particularly concerning considering the issues emanating from the Sandusky scandal,” Mr. DePasquale said.

In an afternoon conference call with reporters, Mr. DePasquale acknowledged that over the last decade the state bears much of the responsibility for tuition increases, given cuts in aid.

Advertise with us

Penn State alluded to that in a lengthy response to the audit. It read in part:

“Access and affordability have been key imperatives for Penn State President Eric Barron since being named the University’s president in 2014. Cost controls have been a focus of the entire University for decades, with nearly $383 million in cuts to recurring costs having been achieved since 1992. It should be acknowledged that Penn State has been able to continue providing access to a quality education to all qualified Pennsylvanians, including the first generation students who make up 27 percent of our student body.

“The University has done so despite receiving one of the lowest levels of per-student support (ranking No. 47 nationally) of any state in the country, which is the primary driver of tuition cost …; further costs include increasing pension and health care costs that are driven significantly by factors outside of the University’s control.” The university said the percentage of higher paying out-of-state students “has remained constant over the past 15 years.”

It continued: “The Legislature’s general support appropriation, used primarily to offset the cost of tuition for Pennsylvania resident students, has steadily decreased over many decades, putting upward pressure on the price of tuition . . . Pennsylvania’s state-related institutions receive far less appropriation per student than peers in other states.”

Mr. DePasquale acknowledged the Legislature has been dealing with its own budget challenges and support for Penn State has decreased as a result, but said the school needs to control its expenses.

Advertise with us

Penn State’s response also questioned the audit’s calculation of missed background checks.

“The Auditor General randomly selected 76 of 732 youth camps held on our campuses for background check compliance.” Although it said even one is too many, it said “the Auditor General’s statement that 57 of the 732 camps were out of compliance is an estimate based on an assumed extrapolation of his statistical sampling and not based in fact.”

According to the audit, Penn State will be implementing changes and expects to have a new human resource system with improved record-keeping and centralization of the background check process in place by the end of this year.

For more than a decade, the share of students from out of state has been rising steadily at many public universities, nationally and in Pennsylvania, including Penn State.

That trend continues.

Advertise with us

Not counting online enrollment, 69 percent of Penn State’s undergraduates in fall 2016 came from Pennsylvania, almost two percentage points less than the previous year. On the main campus, four in 10 undergraduates were from outside Pennsylvania.

The numbers are even more pronounced at the graduate level.

Almost two-thirds of all graduate and professional students at Penn State come from outside the commonwealth. At University Park, three-quarters of graduate students are non-Pennsylvanians.

University leaders say out-of-state enrollment, like international students, brings diversity to campus. Officials also cite the need to compensate for the shrinking supply of traditional-age college students from in-state. They say the university’s strong brand is another factor.

NOTE: This story has been updated from the original to correct “the university’s strong brand” in the final line.

Advertise with us

Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @BschacknerPG.

Penn State's response to the auditor general's performance audit report:

Penn State Auditor General Response (PDF)

Penn State Auditor General Response (Text)