“Right now the bill is dead,” state Sen. Randy Vulakovich, R-Shaler, told those who gathered last week at Fox Chapel Area High School to discuss state education issues with elected officials.

He was referring to Bill 76, which proposes funding Pennsylvania schools by increasing income and sales taxes instead of using property taxes, the current funding source. The bill would not have eliminated property taxes entirely. School districts would still have had the ability to use property taxes to cover existing school debt.

For that reason as well as the loss of local control, Fox Chapel Area administrators do not view the bill as a viable solution to property tax issues.

The April 20 discussion was a meeting of the District Forum, a group of Fox Chapel Area residents that meets regularly to discuss policies and topics of interest to them.

Advertise with us

Mr. Vulakovich said similar school tax bills have been debated in Harrisburg since the 1970s but only recently have progressed to the point of serious consideration. “It’s a very, very big issue,” he said, “especially in Philadelphia.” There are many independent groups organized just to press the issue, he said, adding he expects the discussions on school property taxes to continue.

State Rep. Dom Costa, D-Stanton Heights, agreed with district administrators that using sales taxes would not be a reliable way to fund schools. “I was never for the bill,” he said. “I don’t want to see tax relief at the expense of our children.”

State Rep. Tony DeLuca, D-Penn Hills, said he received at least 500 emails from Fox Chapel Area residents alone. “And they were all the same. You’d have to be out of your mind to say you wouldn’t want property tax relief. But raising personal income taxes and sales taxes is not the way to do it.”

State Rep. Hal English, R-Hampton, agreed. “The four of us at this table don’t see this as a workable solution.”

Fox Chapel Area superintendent Gene Freeman received applause when he suggested that town hall meetings be held across the state before such legislation is proposed again. “If a bill such as this goes through, it’s disastrous,” he said.

Advertise with us

Other education issues also were discussed. Elizabeth Klamut, president of District Forum, asked if the state is considering how to make the Pennsylvania System of School Assessment, or PSSA, and Keystone exams less time-consuming and more useful as tools for measuring student progress.

Mr. Vulakovich said most senators dislike the idea of requiring the Keystone exam as part of a statewide graduation requirement. The General Assembly has decided to delay using the test as a graduation requirement until 2018-19 and has passed legislation asking the state Education Department to study the future of the Keystone exams.

Mr. Costa said the legislation includes reducing the time devoted to testing as well as eliminating redundancies between the PSSA and the Keystone exams. “We want our children to learn, not to take tests,” he said.

“I foresee it eventually going away,” Mr. English said of the proposal to make passing the Keystone exams a graduation requirement.

Mr. Freeman said Fox Chapel Area’s biggest issue with the tests is that the results do not provide any useful feedback for teachers or students.

Advertise with us

The Pennsylvania Public School Employees’ Retirement System was also discussed. Ms. Klamut noted that the district’s state-mandated pension payment increased last year by $4 million. “Our children have to deal with cuts because of the pension,” she said.

The district’s charter school cost — $700,000 last year — also was brought up. “Charter schools are not held to the same standards as brick-and-mortar schools,” Ms. Klamut said. Yet the state mandates that districts pay per pupil fees for the students who attend them.

On the topic of state Bill 383, which would allow school districts to let staff carry guns in schools, Mr. Vulakovich said it is a local issue and districts across the state should be allowed to make their own decisions.

Rita Michel, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.