The new Westinghouse Arts Academy Charter School, which this fall will take up residence in the former Westinghouse Elementary School in Wilmerding, will have room for 750 students.
But only about 1 percent of the students who enroll there will come from the East Allegheny School District, which approved the performing arts high school’s charter in February.
In what some charter school law experts called an “unusual” compromise, the charter school agreed to cap the number of students it takes from East Allegheny at 10. Instead, the school will recruit arts students from other school districts across Allegheny County and beyond.
Given the popularity of Pittsburgh CAPA 6-12 and the Lincoln Park Performing Arts Charter School in Midland, both of which attract hundreds of applicants each year, the new arts-focused high school is likely to be an appealing option for residents outside the city school district or for parents who don’t want to drive their child to Beaver County.
Westinghouse Arts Academy’s founders are counting on it.
“We have no doubt that our school would be able to pull from a pretty large radius,” said Raquel Bouvy, president of the charter school’s board. “We really anticipated getting students from a large number of districts.”
Charter schools are public schools run by private entities and collect “tuition” for each student that attends, which is the equivalent of what that student’s home school district would pay to educate them at their neighborhood school.

Legal experts said it isn’t unusual for Pennsylvania school districts and charter schools to agree on a “cap” that would limit the number of students — and therefore the financial burden — on the authorizing school district. But those limits raise questions about the effects a school board’s vote can have on other school districts.
Frank Pearsol, vice president of the East Allegheny school board, said he considered that dynamic before he joined five other board members by voting for the agreement with the charter school at a Feb. 20 board meeting. Three board members voted against the school.
“I don’t think that there is, in any one district, a large number of students who would qualify to go into that type of a classroom,” Mr. Pearsol said. “I don’t think it will hurt any school district particularly hard.”
Three years in the making
The idea for the school came about more than three years ago, when Ms. Bouvy and others identified a need for specialized arts education in the area, she said.
In 2015-16, the Lincoln Park Performing Arts Charter School drew students from more than 90 different school districts, including one student from East Allegheny, state records show. Pittsburgh CAPA, a magnet school in the Pittsburgh Public Schools district, now has 907 students in sixth through 12th grade. More than 450 students applied to the school last year and 96 are on the waiting list to be admitted. Non-city residents could attend the school, but they are charged more than $15,000 in tuition.
Each Westinghouse Arts Academy student will go through an application and interview process, Ms. Bouvy said. The school will offer instruction in performing arts — such as dance, theater and music — as well as studio arts, digital arts, literary arts and more.
Ms. Bouvy is aware of the “negative connotation” associated with charter schools, which many believe siphon students and money from traditional public schools. But she said that is not the case with the Westinghouse Arts Academy and its unique curriculum.
“It’s not a reflection on [teachers] or the district at all, it’s something different,” she said. “It’s choice. And at the end of the day, it really is for a very different and special kind of student.”
“This was in no way a statement on the kind of education East Allegheny School District was able to provide to their students,” said Amy Heathcott, the charter school’s acting principal. “We provide a level of arts education that no district could provide without a specialized facility.”
She added that the founders of Westinghouse Arts Academy did not want to be a burden to the East Allegheny district or any other school district.
“We know that’s often how charter schools are viewed,” Ms. Heathcott said. “Because we are a specialized school, it’s a very specific kind of student that wants to come to this school. In many cases, a school district is only losing a very small number of students to our charter school, so we don’t end up being that kind of burden to a district.”
About 60 percent of the students’ academic work will be done online, Ms. Heathcott said. And students don’t have to commit themselves to just one study area in the arts.
Informational sessions for parents will start this week in Wilmerding, Plum and on Pittsburgh’s North Side. More will be planned in the North and South Hills, Ms. Heathcott said. The school has already received some applications and hopes to have about 200 students enrolled by the first day of school in the fall.

East Allegheny superintendent Donald Mac Fann called the agreement with the charter school “historic.” In addition to capping the number of students it will take from East Allegheny, the Westinghouse Arts Academy board agreed to cover the transportation costs for those 10 students and offer elective courses each semester for other East Allegheny students who want to take extra arts classes.
As an added benefit, the charter also will pay property taxes for the first five years of the school, and fees in lieu of real estate taxes for the next five years.
The school also will be an asset to the city of Wilmerding, Mr. Mac Fann said. The academy soon will begin renovating the almost 90-year-old former Westinghouse Elementary School building next door to the Westinghouse Castle, which is also undergoing a multimillion-dollar renovation.
“I don’t see any negatives,” he said.
Working together
It isn’t unusual for charter schools and districts to try to negotiate a cap on the number of students the charter school will lure from the district, said Ira Weiss, who serves a solicitor for Pittsburgh Public Schools and several other school districts.
None of the charters authorized by the city school district has ever agreed to a cap, but that doesn’t mean he hasn’t tried to work it into an agreement, Mr. Weiss said. While the caps are legal, a district can’t force that condition on a new charter school.
Mr. Weiss, who also serves as the solicitor for the Montour School District, helped negotiate a 35-student limit when the Montour school board approved a new Propel School in the district a few months ago. But, Mr. Weiss explained, the existing Propel School in the Montour district draws most of its students from surrounding school districts.
“From our perspective, it would appear to be a business decision by the charter,” he said. “They would much rather have the approval than fight about the number of students that can come from East Allegheny.”
Charter schools and school districts can rack up sizable legal fees during the months-long appeals process to the state, which almost always rules in favor of the charter school, Mr. Weiss said.
The implication of a new charter school was not lost on East Allegheny officials when they decided to approve the Westinghouse Arts Academy charter, Mr. Pearsol said.
But the “unique” agreement the district and the school were able to reach — one that both parties say is beneficial — prompted his favorable vote.
“I think East Allegheny in this matter might be a leader in this field,” he said.
Mr. Mac Fann agreed.
“My philosophy was rather than fight this and have them appeal and quite frankly have them get it anyhow, I said ‘Well, let’s work with them and let’s cooperate and try to work with them, as we try to teach our young children,’ ” he said. “It was a good decision, I believe. I’m glad it went the way it went.”
Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1590.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.