Elissa Ridenour was stunned when a friend approached her in the school cafeteria Thursday and said President Donald Trump had rolled back federal protections for transgender students.
His administration’s order, which was issued Wednesday night through the Departments of Education and Justice, reverses a directive put in place by Barack Obama that allowed transgender students to use the bathroom or locker room that corresponds with their gender identity. The new order places the issue in the hands of states and local school districts, which now will be responsible for interpreting federal anti-discrimination law.
“I’m very disappointed,” said Ms. Ridenour, 18. “I knew it could possibly come to this, but I didn’t think it would happen so soon.”
Ms. Ridenour is one of three transgender students who filed a federal lawsuit against the Pine-Richland School District. They sued last fall after the school board enacted a policy requiring them to use facilities consistent with their biological gender.
Lawyers on both sides are waiting to hear the judge’s ruling on that case, which they say could come at any time. And Ms. Ridenour said that although she and her co-plaintiffs are hopeful they will win their case, she wonders whether she will experience more bullying than usual from those who believe the new order has given them permission to discriminate against transgender people.
“I was very shaken up about it,” she said. “It’s already been stressful, but just adding on this now is even more stressful. I need to focus on other things, like college acceptances and all that other fun stuff that a senior is supposed to be thinking about.”
Read More
One of the co-plaintiffs in the Pine-Richland lawsuit is Juliet Evancho, 18, a transgender woman who is the older sister of singer Jackie Evancho. Jackie Evancho, who sang the national anthem at Mr. Trump’s inauguration, took to Twitter on Wednesday night to express her disappointment with Mr. Trump’s stance and pleaded with him to meet with her and her sister.
. @realDonaldTrump u gave me the honor 2 sing at your inauguration. Pls give me & my sis the honor 2 meet with u 2 talk #transgender rghts ❤
— jackie evancho (@jackieevancho) February 23, 2017
I am obviously disappointed in the @POTUS decision to send the #transgender bathroom issue to the states to decide. #sisterlove
— jackie evancho (@jackieevancho) February 22, 2017
Although Mr. Trump has not commented on the matter, ABC News reported Thursday that White House press secretary Sean Spicer said in a briefing that he believes the president “would be welcome to meet with her.”
A federal judge in Texas put a temporary hold on the Obama guidance soon after it was issued — and after 13 states sued — so legal experts say the new directive does not have an impact on local district policy. But advocates for transgender students said it was a signal from the new administration that it won’t provide them with sufficient protection.
Equality Pennsylvania, an LGBT advocacy group, said in a statement Thursday that revoking the Obama-era guidance “is indicative of the administration’s disregard for transgender youth and the many challenges they face.”
“While it may not have a legal impact, it sends an alarming messaging that bullying and harassment are OK,” the group said.
Casey Smith, a spokeswoman for the Pennsylvania Department of Education, said the agency is reviewing the new guidelines and will work with Gov. Tom Wolf to “ensure the protection of all students in schools across the commonwealth, no matter their race, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression.”
“Governor Wolf is committed to ensuring Pennsylvania remains a place where everyone feels welcome, and those protections must extend to our classrooms and schools,” she said.
Pittsburgh Public Schools board member Moira Kaleida said the district's nondiscrimination policy for transgender students, which she advocated for last year, will remain in effect.
“Pittsburgh Public remains committed to protecting our transgender and gender nonconforming students, and we won't stand for the bullying and discrimination that goes along with this directive,” she said.
Thank you to the LGBT community! I will fight for you while Hillary brings in more people that will threaten your freedoms and beliefs.
— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) June 14, 2016
It remains unclear what impact the directive could have on pending court cases on the federal sex discrimination law, Title IX, including a case to be heard by the Supreme Court in March involving Gavin Grimm, a transgender teen who was denied bathroom access in Virginia.
Omar Gonzalez-Pagan, a staff attorney with Washington, D.C.-based advocacy group Lambda Legal, which is representing the Pine-Richland students, said it won’t affect their case at all.
But the order does leave some districts that don't have such a policy wondering whether they should enact one themselves, said Emily Leader, an attorney with the Pennsylvania School Boards Association.
“They’re not arguing that you can’t have a policy one way or another, they’re just saying we’re not interpreting the law this way anymore,” she said about the administration’s order. “What we’ve consistently told districts is that [the PSBA] can’t write formal policy on this until the law is settled.”
The outcome of the Pine-Richland case could provide useful guidance to districts across Pennsylvania, Ms. Leader said.
“It will be awhile until things feel more clear-cut, but that’s not unusual with issues when they’re first developing in the courts,” she said. “I think our strongest concern is students. Give students dignity and protect students from harassment if it’s happening and be compassionate in whatever you do.”
Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1590. Molly Born: Mborn@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1944.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.