An Allegheny County Common Pleas judge on Wednesday dismissed a lawsuit against the Pittsburgh Public Schools over the sale late last year of the Gladstone Middle School property in Hazelwood.
An attorney for Gaugamela Holdings, which filed the lawsuit, said it could refile an amended complaint or appeal the decision to Superior Court.
Gladstone Community Partnership, a group including the Center of Life youth development nonprofit, the Hazelwood Initiative, the Pittsburgh Community Reinvestment Group and the Make it Right Foundation, paid $250,000 for the 145,000-square-foot building, which includes 6.6 acres of property. The project proposal includes an early childhood development center, mixed-income housing, headquarters for The Mission Continues veterans group and possibly a full-service health care center.
The sale closed in November.
But Gaugamela, a technology incubator that focuses on ornamental horticulture, put in its own bid on the property when Gladstone was first listed for sale in 2015. The firm, which currently operates in Uptown, offered $1.5 million for the property, hoping to be the anchor tenant and open the rest of the space for other similar companies.
In a vote on Nov. 24, 2015, the school board approved the bid from the community partnership, even though Gaugamela’s offer was six times more.
During oral argument on preliminary objections Wednesday, school solicitor Ira Weiss told Judge Michael Della Vecchia that board members were fearful that Gaugamela did not have the financial wherewithal to pay the price offered for the property.
“The proposal was deemed to not be responsible,” Mr. Weiss said.
The board conducted a financial background check to ensure Gaugamela could finance the project, Mr. Weiss said, and when contacted, people whose names were listed as backing the project said they were not associated with the company.
Jeffrey Morris, the attorney representing Gaugamela, strongly objected to Mr. Weiss’ statements, telling the court that a motion hearing was not the proper venue to assert them.
Further, Mr. Morris said his client was never told any such thing by the school district. Francis Pitt, the CEO of Gaugamela, said after the hearing that Mr. Weiss’ comments were untrue.
Both sides argued technicalities in the case.
Gaugamela’s attorney said the city schools didn’t follow the state statute’s requirement that it obtain three sworn affidavits setting a value on the property, and instead only offered appraisals. Two of those valued the property at $215,000, while one listed it at zero, because of the potential environmental remediation costs.
The school solicitor said Gaugamela did not file the proper type of complaint in the case and should have instead moved to stop the sale last year before it occurred.
“The remedy was to seek to enjoin the sale beforehand,” Mr. Weiss said. “He’s representing a disappointed bidder.”
The judge concurred. “Shouldn’t you have been quicker? [I]sn’t the horse out of the barn?”
“Absolutely not,” Mr. Morris answered. “The transaction can be rescinded.”
Judge Della Vecchia granted the school district’s preliminary objections claiming that Gaugamela failed to assert an appropriate claim and dismissed the complaint. However, Gaugamela can refile an amended complaint within 30 days.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.