Two months after armed police officers began working in the Gateway School District, state Commonwealth Court affirmed that the school board, not a trial judge, has the right to decide whether its officers carry weapons.
In an 11-page opinion filed Wednesday, a three-judge panel of the appellate court said the only authority a Common Pleas Court judge has over the question of officers in schools is whether someone applying to work in the district meets state Department of Education requirements.
“It is not within the trial court’s discretion to approve or disapprove whether there should be a school police force or what powers that school police force should exercise,” wrote Senior Judge Dan Pellegrini.
The opinion was in response to a ruling by Common Pleas Senior Judge Timothy O’Reilly, who denied Gateway’s petition to hire an armed police force. In his September opinion, Judge O’Reilly wrote that “it’s not a good idea” for Gateway to implement an independent armed police force, because it could lead to “super discipline,” and potential abuses. He also suggested more training was necessary for the officers and that the school board’s decision to arm them was hasty.
Gateway attorneys argued that Judge O’Reilly had no authority to reach that conclusion.
The district then filed a separate petition in criminal court before Common Pleas President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning requesting armed officers He granted the request.
In its opinion, Commonwealth Court said it is the responsibility of a trial judge to ensure that the appointment of individual officers is proper, and that they have state-required certification.
Gateway school board president Chad Stubenbort said the part-time officers working there now — all retired state troopers or municipal police officers -— meet the requirements.
“I think it’s definitely an improvement from what we did have, with unarmed security guards,” he said. “Their professionalism shows in their interaction with students.”
The district previously employed two school resource officers, from the Monroeville and Pitcairn police departments, as well as security guards. Implementing the part-time, certified force was more cost-effective, Mr. Stubenbort said, and provides increased safety.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.