Jessica Tilli’s days are packed as a teacher leader at Meredith Elementary School in South Philadelphia, but she spends spare minutes calling, emailing and even faxing lawmakers to stop what she believes is a looming crisis for the children she teaches.
“I really can’t believe that an incompetent billionaire is buying oversight of 50 million schoolchildren,” said Tilli.
Progressives of all stripes have mounted an all-out attack on President Donald Trump’s nomination of prominent Republican donor and school-choice and voucher advocate Betsy DeVos as education secretary.
In Philadelphia, teachers have taken her selection particularly seriously.
Tilli has long been passionate about public education, she said, but has no experience planning protests. Still, she’s scheduled one for Friday after school, and expects hundreds to converge outside Sen. Pat Toomey’s Philadelphia office to publicly demand he vote against Trump’s pick, who has never attended or sent children to a public school.
It’s far from the first Philadelphia action aimed at Toomey. It’s not even the first one this week.
Read More
Toomey has pledged support for DeVos, whose nomination will be go to a final U.S. Senate vote next week. And although two Republicans have broken ranks and said they will oppose DeVos, it appears that she will still win confirmation.
But no votes have been taken, Tilli points out, and as long as that’s the case, she and other teachers — and parents, and people who care about education — will be rallying in every way they can think of.
“If teachers and students and families who will be affected by this, then we’re sending another message, that we do not object,” said Tilli.
DeVos has been criticized for her performance at her confirmation hearing, appearing confused about key provisions of federal law. She wasn’t clear, for instance, on the Department of Education’s role in enforcing the federal Individuals with Disabilities Act — she said it should be left to the states to decide how to handle it.
Opposing DeVos feels personal to Dave Malone, a teacher at Widener Memorial School.
Widener is the Philadelphia School District’s school for children with medical and physical disabilities, and that a potential education secretary would appear to be unfamiliar with the federal law that guarantees rights for its children is beyond frightening, he said.
So he’s spending his spare time dialing on DeVos — mostly phoning Republican Pennsylvania Sen. Pat Toomey, whose offices have been so blanketed by calls that getting through is typically impossible. Malone might eat his lunch while making calls, or spend time after school trying to get through. And he’s enlisted help.
“I’m trying to fire up the teachers in my building, getting them to call senators around the country to let them know that we’re not happy,” Malone said. “Every phone call counts. I encourage them to call several times. Some of them may not hear us — they oppose what we think — but they’re taking note that we’re calling.”
Teachers’ unions across the country have been pushing hard on DeVos, and Hillary Linardopoulos, the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers’ legislative representative, said Philadelphia teachers have shown up in force.
By PFT estimates, teachers have logged 5,000 calls to senators urging them to vote her down, Linardopoulos said — one teacher recently sent her a screen shot from her phone, noting that the teacher had made 100 calls to Toomey’s office in a day, only getting voicemail once.
The rest of the calls, she said, yielded busy signals or no answer at all.
“I think our members really see the significance of calling out our elected officials when they are not standing up for our kids,” Linardopoulos said. “It’s about our moral compass. People are furious, and they’ve shown that they’re willing to fight.”
DeVos seems to be a lock, but the PFT isn’t letting up.
“Until the final vote is in taken, this is in play,” Linardopoulos said.
Katherine Fritz, a South Philadelphia teaching artist and adjunct community college professor, has also taken up the cause. Furious at the DeVos nomination, she launched a GoFundMe campaign to raise $55,800 — the amount DeVos's family donated to Toomey — to “buy Pat Toomey’s vote,” she wrote breezily.
“Betsy DeVos has never set foot in a classroom, did not send her children to public school, cannot distinguish between proficiency and growth, and thinks that guns should be allowed in schools in the event of grizzly attacks. That fictitious grizzly is about as qualified as Ms. DeVos to run the Department of Education,” wrote Fritz.
As of Friday morning, she had raised over $30,000. (She will donate the funds to a girls’ leadership camp in Philadelphia, the Children’s Literacy Initiative, and the Pennsylvania Arts Education Network, organizations that will need the funds in the Trump era, she said.)
Fritz watched every minute of DeVos’ confirmation hearing in horror, pretty sure that she knew more than DeVos about public education, she said.
And that Toomey seems “poised to vote for her despite the fact that every educator I know has been calling and faxing his office every day begging him to listen to them — I just — it seems like such a blatant display of conflicts of interest,” Fritz said. “This shouldn’t be OK.”
She is astounded that her online, jokey plea for funds has gone viral.
“But I think it speaks to the anger and frustration and passion that a lot of people are feeling on this issue right now,” Fritz said. “They’ve already tweeted, Facebooked, emailed, petitioned, called, faxed, sent letters and protested, and when you don’t feel like your voice is being heard, well, maybe if I get out my credit card, it will send a message.”
City Councilwoman Helen Gym, a longtime public education activist, has also been vocal on the issue. On Wednesday, she and disability rights advocates scored a coup, rallying outside Toomey’s Philadelphia office and even managing to hand-deliver a letter to a Toomey staffer.
Yes, it looks like DeVos may well be confirmed, Gym said, but this is not the end.
“Whoever gets confirmed doesn’t even know what they’ve got coming,” Gym said. “When we can organize our communities at this level, it is setting the parameters about how we’re going to fight for public education. The fight is being shaped by the communities.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.