Antonette Farrah enrolled her son at St. Teresa of Avila School two years ago because of the all-day kindergarten program.

She and her husband talked about moving him to a public school, but they loved the Catholic school in Ross so much they decided not only to keep him there, but also to enroll their daughter.

They may weigh their options again soon, though, if the Diocese of Pittsburgh eliminates the pre-kindergarten through eighth grade model that is so distinctive to Catholic elementary education. That is a possibility at some schools under a new “regionalization” plan in the North Hills.

“I think dissolving the K-8 model, I think that is detrimental,” Ms. Farrah said, likening the potential change to a “death spiral” for Catholic education. “It’s one of the reasons that I and many other parents chose to do Catholic schools instead of public.”

Advertise with us

Under the proposed regionalization plan, the diocese would combine:

• St. Alexis in McCandless and St. Alphonsus in Pine;

• Assumption in Bellevue and Northside Catholic in Brighton Heights;

• St. Bonaventure in Shaler, St. Mary of the Assumption and St. Ursula, both in Hampton;

• St. Sebastian and St. Teresa of Avila, both in Ross.

Advertise with us

Two other schools, Christ the Divine Teacher in Aspinwall and St. James in Sewickley, are part of the 11-school region but already are regional schools.

Appointed task forces representing each of the North Hills schools were sorted into groups based on which schools would merge under the proposed change.

The diocese has charged the teams with coming up with a solution to rapidly declining enrollment at each of the schools and developing a plan that allows for future growth. Discussions have started about whether to keep the K-8 model at their schools or split them into elementary and middle schools.

The recommendations of the groups will be part of a larger plan to consolidate the school administrations. Rather than be supported by a single parish, each school will be supported by 32 parishes in the North Hills. The schools will each have a principal, but a regional administrator will oversee operations and a nonprofit will be formed to administer programming.

The school changes are part of the larger On Mission for the Church Alive restructuring plan, in which the Pittsburgh diocese is attempting to combine an evangelistic push with the need to get leaner amid declining membership and Mass attendance. Enrollment in the diocese’s elementary schools has declined by about 50 percent since 2000, according to the diocese.

Advertise with us

Parents at the North Hills schools were given preliminary information during meetings in the past two weeks and will be asked to participate in a survey once the task force groups finalize their proposals about new school models. Bishop David Zubik will be given the proposals and the survey results in late December and is expected to make a final decision by the end of January. Eventually, the plan will expand to the other elementary schools within the diocese.

“I don’t want my children to be the guinea pigs of that model,” Ms. Farrah said about the potential move away from K-8.

She’s not the only one. At a meeting for St. Teresa and St. Sebastian parents last week, most parents were opposed to the idea of having children in separate schools or moving them to new schools every few years. The diocese plans to merge the two schools, but parents are skeptical that either of the buildings could hold their combined 600 students. Ms. Farrah said because of that, she believes the older and younger students will likely be split onto separate campuses.

Meredith Kandravy, a parent and task force member for St. Mary of the Assumption, is optimistic that the K-8 model can be maintained there. St. Mary would merge with St. Bonaventure and St. Ursula. Because the combined enrollment is about 360, she believes all students in all grades could fit in one building.

Keeping the K-8 model is important to the parents at those schools, too, Ms. Kandravy said.

Advertise with us

“That’s sort of been how we’re approaching all of decision-making,” she said.

A diocesan spokesman stressed last week that no final decisions have been made, and until they are, officials won’t know whether there will be any school closures or how the changes will affect tuition.

“An important goal of regionalization is to strengthen and promote quality Catholic education,” diocesan spokesman Bob DeWitt said in an email. “Students benefit from rigorous academics while learning the values of faith, hope, love and community.”

During meetings with parents, diocesan officials said Catholic dioceses in Milwaukee and Green Bay in Wisconsin have had success with similar regional structures.

The Diocese of Erie is rolling out a plan for its schools. After protests from parents about a plan to separate the elementary- and middle-school students onto separate campuses, the diocese came up with a new one, said the Rev. Nicholas Rouch, vicar for education in the Erie diocese.

Advertise with us

Instead of creating separate pre-Kindergarten through fifth grade schools and two middle schools, they created “embedded middle schools” under the same roof as the elementary schools, Father Rouch said. But the diocese was forced to close two grade schools.

Many Catholic schools are battling not only a drop in enrollment, but a greater reliance on subsidies from their parishes, which are also seeing a decline in attendance, Father Rouch said.

“That model is starting to show its weaknesses,” he said about parish schools.

As in the North Hills, the remaining Erie schools will share an administrative structure and rely on the support of multiple parishes, not just one.

Ms. Farrah said she likes the shared administration of all the North Hills schools, but hopes diocesan officials and the task force groups will listen to concerns from parents.

Advertise with us

“Parents, we’re the heart of these schools,” Ms. Farrah said. “We put lots of effort into fundraising and volunteering. I really hope that they all hear us and do what’s best for our children.”

Elizabeth Behrman: 412-263-1590 or lbehrman@post-gazette.com.