Former U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan in an open letter to college presidents and education school deans said the system for training teachers “lacks rigor, is out of step with the times” and leaves them “unprepared and their future students at risk.” His letter was posted Tuesday on the website of the Brookings Institution, a Washington D.C.-based think tank, where he is a nonresident senior fellow.
A Brookings’ spokeswoman said Mr. Duncan hopes to spark a conversation about teacher preparation programs, something he also tried when he led the education department. The criticism is hardly new and comes as fewer students are entering teacher preparation programs nationally.
“We should ensure that they’re held to high standards like engineering, business, and medical students,” he wrote of the nation’s prospective teachers, “and we should only be giving the best grades to those teacher candidates who are most prepared for the classroom.”
Mr. Duncan, who oversaw education under President Barack Obama from 2009 until earlier this year, cited a 2014 report by the National Council on Teacher Quality that found some of the biggest teacher training programs are twice as likely to graduate students with honors than other programs at those colleges. About 30 percent of all students graduated with honors compared to 44 percent of education majors, the study found.
Mr. Duncan cited several Pennsylvania colleges, including Cedar Crest in Allentown where, he said, 80 percent of education students graduated with honors compared to 26 percent of all students and Penn State Harrisburg which had a 44-point gap. The report also showed gaps at several of Pennsylvania’s state system universities, including West Chester and Bloomsburg.
“There can only be two explanations for this unsettling phenomenon: either your teacher training programs are attracting an unusually gifted group of students or the standard for honors in education is too low,” Mr. Duncan wrote.
Some educators took exception to Mr. Duncan’s critique, saying he unfairly based his observations on one report and that relying on letter grades to evaluate programs is ill-advised.
“He actually has a very narrow perspective,” and an outdated one, said Kenneth Witmer, Jr., dean of West Chester University’s College of Education and Social Work. “His article sounds like something my grandfather would have written.”
Mr. Witmer said the criticism is unfair to West Chester, which has the requirement that students entering the major have a 3.0 GPA. It makes sense, he said, that students in the program get higher grades because those with lower grades already have been weeded out.
Sr. Duncan singled out Hunter College in New York for using more vigorous evaluation criteria.
The college “requires their teacher candidates to record themselves teaching on video and then later document and analyze their own instruction; this allows professors to see both the instruction choices and the candidates’ analysis of their work,” he wrote.
Pam Grossman, dean of University of Pennsylvania’s graduate school of education, said other schools, including Penn, are doing that kind of evaluation. Penn also requires teacher candidates to spend 900 hours in classrooms working with classroom teachers, twice the national average, she said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.