Gateway School District will appeal a court decision that it cannot have an armed police force in its schools.

The district also is exploring the idea of having all students wear school uniforms.

The school board voted 8-1 on Tuesday to appeal Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Timothy O’Reilly’s denial of the district’s request for an armed police force. Board member Stephanie Byrne dissented.

Board president Chad Stubenbort said the appeal would be filed in the next couple days.

Advertise with us

He said Judge O’Reilly would first have a chance to re-examine his decision. If he still says no, Mr. Stubenbort said, a formal appeal process would begin with a new judge.

In his nine-page opinion issued Sept. 15, Judge O’Reilly said  “it’s not a good idea” to implement an independent, private 11-officer police force and that not enough thought was put into the plan.

“In a nutshell, I will NOT sign the petition because more thought needs to be put into this proposition and more training needs to be developed for those who will be armed police officers,” he wrote.

Board member Valerie Warning, who noted that she had thought the judge would approve the armed force, said, “We had no backup plan and we still have no plan. We need to get something in place.”

Board member Neal Nola said that if an incident occurred, Monroeville police would be called.

Advertise with us

He added that having armed officers in the schools is not something new in the district — the only thing that is new is having them in the elementary schools. Previously, the district worked with Monroeville and Pitcairn police departments to have officers at the high school and Gateway Middle School.

“This was more than planned,” he said. “This was talked about for more than a year. All we’re doing is protecting more of what we have.”

Board member Mary Beth Cirucci said Judge O’Reilly was “trying to create our program for us.”

“He is not quoting the law, he’s quoting his own opinion,” she said.

She said she is confident the board will win its appeal. In the meantime, she said, “We sill have men in the schools performing security-type duties.”

Advertise with us

In June, the board voted 7-2 to authorize a petition to the court to approve “duly trained and appointed school police officers pursuant to the Pennsylvania School Code.”

Gateway filed its petition July 19 and argued the issue on Aug. 22. The board hired 11 officers, including two supervisors in August, earning between $18 and $23 per hour, and approved spending $18,000 on uniforms and equipment. The officers are currently working as unarmed security guards at each of the district’s schools.

On the possibility of having students wear school uniforms, the board voted unanimously to get input from students, parents, teachers, administrators and the community on such a policy. The district is developing a survey to gather the data.

“It’s truly to gauge the public’s opinion,” superintendent Bill Short said.

Mr. Short said the administration has started to obtain information from other school districts that have implemented or attempted to implement a uniform policy.

Advertise with us

Board member Steve O’Donnell, who presented the resolution regarding uniforms, said uniforms “may well reduce cost for parents” and eliminate “exaggerated dress.”

“It speaks to an expectation of excellence,” he said.

Mr. O’Donnell said the district does not intend to implement a policy this year.

“We want to give everybody plenty of notice,” he said.

“This is simply having the district look into the possibility,” Mr. Stubenbort said.

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.