More than 75 parents and educators crowded into the small room where the Mars Area school board meets, spilling into the vestibule, to voice their displeasure with the board’s rejection of a fact-finding report in a labor dispute with support staff.
Board members voted 8-1 a second time Tuesday to reject the report. The second vote was required by law because members of the Mars Area Education Support Staff had approved the report. Board member Steve Boggs was the lone dissenting vote both times.
Those who spoke were unanimous in their view that the district should offer the support staff — paraprofessionals, secretaries and custodians — a fair contract and not outsource their jobs.
The district is considering outsourcing custodial services to save $1 million per year. Outsourcing paraprofessionals and secretaries would save another $800,000 a year, but the board currently is looking to outsource only custodians, solicitor Tom Breth said.
“Outsourcing will fill our buildings with people who will be on the lookout for other jobs …a transient work force that we have not hired or trained,” second-grade teacher Vicki Stenner said. “Would we want a stranger with ulterior motives to have access to our computers [and] confidential records?”
Mrs. Stenner said the custodians look out for the teachers when they come in early or work late. They also go above and beyond their jobs to help out.
“They have kept chicks alive and incubators warm during power outages, built platforms to go beneath the desks of small children … and gone ‘dumpster diving’ in search of lost dental retainers,” she said.
Others took the board to task for spending money on two new softball fields and attempting to take over soccer fields that are owned by the Mars Home for Youth.
“If the Mars School District is hurting for money, which I doubt, cut a few unnecessary expenses — two $800,000 sports fields which may not be necessary at this time,” Terry Caldwell said.
Some staff and parents talked about problems with services that were previously outsourced. Parent Lori Allison said she quit being a substitute teacher in the district because the company hired to manage substitutes kept asking her to teach classes for which she was not certified. “They only wanted a body,” she said.
Mr. Breth said the main sticking point in negotiations is the district’s insistence that all employees be treated the same for health care costs. Under the current contract, which expired June 30, 2015, the district pays only for individual health coverage for new employees rather than family coverage that existing employees receive. Employees can opt to pay for family coverage themselves if they want it.
Family coverage costs $18,000 per year per employee, while individual coverage costs approximately $6,000, Mr. Breth said.
“In 2012, both parties acknowledged that the compensation structure under the collective bargaining agreement was not sustainable. … Economics have not changed,” he said. “The way to avoid subcontracting out any of these classifications is for the association to … agree to a fair contract. Bring all folks under same compensation structure.”
Sandy Trozzo, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.