Three geologists at University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown believe that a luxury outdoor club, whose member list included Andrew Carnegie, Henry Clay Frick and Andrew Mellon, may have been partially responsible for the 1889 Johnstown flood.
A recent study conducted by professors Uldis Kaktins, Neil Coleman and Stephanie Wojno found that the exclusive South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club, to which the industrialists belonged, was likely responsible for an 1889 flood that killed more than 2,200 people in Johnstown and its surrounding towns. At the time, it represented the single greatest loss of life in American history, according to the Johnstown Flood Memorial Museum.
In 1879, the club purchased the South Fork Dam, attached to Lake Conemaugh, and made a variety of dangerous modifications that included clogging its spillways to keep in the lake’s fish, and lowering the crest several feet for easy carriage access to the lodge. They also failed to adequately maintain the dam’s original 1853 specifications.
On May 31, 1889, the dam failed, releasing 20 million gallons of water in a 37-foot-tall wave that killed thousands and cost millions in damages.
In the following years, club members argued that extreme weather, rather than the extremely wealthy were to blame for the dam’s failure. They backed up this claim with an 1891 report from a prestigious committee from the American Society of Civil Engineers, which asserted that the South Fork Dam collapsed after several days of heavy rain. The club’s modifications, the engineering society believed, did not contribute to the Johnstown flood.
For 127 years, ASCE’s initial findings were highly disputed, but never scientifically disproven.
“These men can’t come back and defend themselves, so we tried to be respectful of their findings, when we conducted our study,” said Mr. Coleman. “But even for 1891 this report was state-of-the-art, and there were certain things they should have seen.”
Using hydraulic analysis and modern mapping technology, Mr. Coleman, along with Mr. Kaktins and Ms. Wojno, spent five years evaluating the conclusion of the 1891 report.
Mr. Kaktins died July 3, shortly after the report was published. A professor of earth and energy resources at school since the 1970s, Mr. Kaktins taught Mr. Coleman and Ms. Wojno during their undergraduate years at the university.
“He was a remarkable scientist and professor, and it was an an absolute privilege to work with him,” Mr. Coleman said. He added that as a local geologist, Mr. Kaktins had always been intrigued by the local flood that claimed more than 2,200 lives. According to Mr. Coleman, Mr. Kaktins had been exposed to historical writings about the flood throughout his career, but believed that many of their claims were never properly investigated.
“There were a lot of claims made, but it always disturbed us that they hadn’t been scientifically tested,” Mr. Coleman said.
The primary claim they investigated was that the dam would have collapsed regardless of various changes and modifications the club had made since purchasing the dam in 1879.
Club members lowered the crest in several places to make it easier for carriages to cross, placed screens on top of the spillway to prevent fish from escaping the man-made lake, and failed to replace five drain pipes that could have been used to lower water levels.
By making these changes, the Pitt-Johnstown geologists believe the dam’s discharge capacity was cut in half. According to the team’s calculations, this higher-capacity dam would have prevented overtopping for around 14 hours, rather than 65 minutes.
They also found that two of the engineers sent to investigate the Johnstown flood had previously investigated the failure of another dam in 1874. Although the incidents were similar, the engineers presented very different findings.
“In that report, they lambasted the whole operation,” Mr. Coleman said. “The owners, the materials they used, the builders — everything. But you see an entirely different philosophy appear at Johnstown, when they’re investigating a dam owned by the greatest industrialists and financiers in the country.”
He added that although the flood was a tragedy, it became a valuable learning experience.
Greg Scott, a senior engineer at Buchart Horn and an ex-president of ASCE’s Pittsburgh chapter, acknowledged the 1889 flood as somewhat of a “black eye on the history of ASCE.” “Johnstown was a catastrophe,” Mr. Scott said. “But it made people think, ‘Wow, we should have a program that regulates this kind of thing.’ It gave birth to the idea of critical infrastructure, and that it can kill us if we don’t take care of it.”
Today, 49 states have some form of dam regulatory system.
Beyond providing new answers to an old story, Mr. Coleman said he plans to use the findings in future studies analyzing potential effects of lake drainage.
“It’s always a good lesson to learn from bad examples,” Mr. Coleman said. “The only good thing that comes from tragedies is that we learn what not to do. It’s an important take-away, especially when thousands of lives are lost.”
Madeline Kennedy: madelinekennedy@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1449.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.