The future superintendent of the Pittsburgh Public Schools on Tuesday defended his work transforming struggling schools in Florida. But Anthony Hamlet’s resume still drew questions, both for his claims about his past performance and for language that appears to be taken without attribution from other sources.
Mr. Hamlet’s resume included statistics about improving student performance at two Palm Beach County schools where he served as principal. But last week, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and the Palm Beach Post reported that some of those numbers appeared to be at odds with state data.
“It is unfortunate that we have begun this way,” Mr. Hamlet, 46, said at the district’s administration building Tuesday. But “I look forward to working with the board, the schools, the community, the families, and more importantly, the students, to continue some of the great work already taking place in the district.”
Mr. Hamlet’s resume claimed a high school and a middle school “moved from ‘F’ to ‘C’” during his tenure. On Tuesday, he acknowledged his resume was in error about John F. Kennedy Middle, which state records show improving from D to C.
But Mr. Hamlet justified the failing grade his resume gave Palm Beach Lakes High, where he was principal from August 2011 to June 2014.
State records show the school earning a C grade throughout his tenure. But on Tuesday, Mr. Hamlet focused solely on the standardized test scores of students, which account for half of the state Department of Education-assigned composite letter grade. The rest of the grade is compiled from factors such as graduation rates, college readiness and student participation in accelerated courses.
Read More
Mr. Hamlet argued the state’s composite score for Lakes “masked that lack of academic achievement happening within the school” prior to his arrival. In a chart, he cited state data showing student test scores rising between 2011 and 2013. A state-tabulated score showed an improvement from 391 to 439 out of a possible 800 during that time.
But Cheryl Etters, a spokeswoman for the state Department of Education, noted that “there is no separate grading scale for only the [test-driven] performance components.” And the school’s performance in other categories declined in that period, enough to offset improvements in test scores.
As a result, the school’s composite grade was exactly the same at the end of Mr. Hamlet’s tenure as in the year before he became principal.
Mr. Hamlet also sought to rebut media reports questioning his original resume’s claim that graduation rates at the high school improved from 59 percent to 72 percent. He presented a chart that did show increases in graduation rates. But neither the chart nor a Post-Gazette review of state figures reflected an increase of 13 percentage points. (A revised resume sent to the Post-Gazette on Friday had graduation rates similar to those he presented Tuesday.)
Media accounts also said that a drop in suspensions at Lakes was smaller than his resume claimed. On Tuesday, Mr. Hamlet said his resume counted the total number of suspensions, including those of students who had been disciplined multiple times. The state data cited by the Post-Gazette last week, he said, reflected “unduplicated suspensions,” in which each student was counted once, no matter how many times the person was suspended.
“I believe today I have answered these questions,” Mr. Hamlet said.
Mr. Hamlet did, however, brush aside a Post-Gazette reporter who raised a new question about the statement of “educational philosophy” on his resume.
The statement begins by asserting, “A successful superintendent has to satisfy many constituencies, keeping high achievers in the system while devoting resources to those who need them most.” That line appears nearly verbatim — with the addition of a single word — in a Washington Post editorial dated Feb. 3, 2015.
“That’s my educational philosophy,” Mr. Hamlet said after the news conference.
The resume also borrowed descriptive language from programs Mr. Hamlet attended.
School board president Regina Holley and the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers defended Mr. Hamlet Tuesday.
Calling the resume questions a “closed matter,” Ms. Holley said the board had discussion with Mr. Hamlet about earlier media reports. “He had to tell us what numbers he used,” she said, adding the district’s data team also provided expertise. In general, she said, “The numbers that we saw showed improvement ... for a very challenged population.”
Teachers union president Nina Esposito-Visgitis said in a statement, “We remain supportive of the school board’s process to develop a community vision for our schools by seeking extensive public input and then looking for a superintendent that shares our collective vision. We believe that Dr. Anthony Hamlet does share that vision.”
Not everyone was convinced.
“Sometimes there can be different interpretations of data. That happens,” said Sala Udin, a former Pittsburgh City Council member and co-chair of the Hill District Education Council. But he said the issue hadn’t been put to rest yet. “I came in with concerns, and I still have concerns.”
“We are concerned about the issues, and will be diligent in monitoring them,” said Tracey Reed Armant, board chair of educational advocacy group A+ Schools.
“You can make data say whatever you want,” said Cate Reed, the treasurer of a new political action committee, Campaign for Quality Schools Pittsburgh, that plans to fund candidates for school board next year.
“My issue is less with Dr. Hamlet than with the board saying, ‘He can explain this stuff away,’ ” Ms. Reed said. “But why did you let it get this far?”
Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com. Chris Potter: cpotter@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.