At the first school board meeting following the state auditor general’s scathing findings about district financial controls, Penn Hills residents and board members expressed their anger.
School board president Denise Graham-Shealy addressed the audience at Linton Middle school by allowing public comments at the meeting’s outset and asking for restraint.
“There are many pieces to this puzzle. These issues started in 2009 and continued to this year. Every board member that served in that time has a piece of this puzzle,” she said.
“To put it bluntly, we failed. It’s a bitter pill. This board is focused on rebuilding and figuring out how to get out of this mess. That’s what this is, a mess. I say to all of you, don’t get mad at each other and tear this community apart.”
“All of us are angry, frustrated and accusatory,” Virginia Dougherty of Hulton Road told the board. “We feel like caged animals who turn against one another. But we must find common ground and we must not be lax in our individual responsibility. It’s not where you start but where you are going.”
Former school board member Carolyn Faggioli pointed to a failure of having accurate information from administrators and other advisers. “I am disappointed in the auditor’s report. We knew this was going on. [Former business manager Richard] Liberto told us for years this was coming. He asked the board to furlough teachers but we called them all back because we didn’t want to see our friends go. The thing that caught my eye was having Mr. Liberto being the secretary and treasurer. School code prohibits that. I would think the solicitor would know that. There should have been a forensic audit.”
Read More
“Carolyn, you voted against it,” interjected board member Erin Vecchio.
Several times throughout the meeting, board member Pauline Calabrese called for some form of state intervention. During the vote on approval of monthly finances, Ms. Calabrese made her case. “I have utmost confidence in our superintendent and business manager, but will vote no on every item. I believe we need state intervention. Not a takeover, but something as simple as an advisory capacity.” She suggested asking the state to provide a low-interest loan to replace the $20 million bond issue executed last fall to cover the district’s deficit.
Superintendent Nancy Hines said, “As the auditor general noted, Penn Hills is a prime candidate for being declared a distressed district. It is an option, but the Department of Education is not moving in that direction. Penn Hills has changed and we are moving on,” she said.
“The district has been instituting corrective measures and we are in the process of providing a good education while making efficient use of our financial resources. This is still very tenuous. It is not a cakewalk. But Moody’s [Investment Service] released a statement today that says the auditor general’s report indicates a pathway to slowly return to sound financial status.”
In still more fallout from the audit, the board voted unanimously to permanently exclude A.J. Myers and Sons, Inc. from bidding on any contracted services.
Based upon results of the audit, Penn Hills failed to limit the transportation contractor’s access to district fuel supplies, which resulted in the misappropriation of fuel costing between $260,000 and $384,500.
Security cameras installed at the maintenance facility showed Myers employees filling up vehicles that were not used to transport district students.
In addition, the district did not review bus driver background checks. Two had criminal convictions and have since been fired.
Tim Means, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.