How on earth am I going to remember any of this?

This was one of many thoughts racing through my head as I, then a high school sophomore, struggled through my first college tour. The campus seemed huge. Between the dorm rooms, the meal plans and the class schedules, the amount of information being thrown at us was overwhelming. Yet somehow, I still couldn’t picture what exactly going to college would be like — or, more pressing, how I would decide which school to attend in the first place.

In particular, I worried about finding the perfect fit. How could I find a college where people would share my enthusiasm for geeking out about “The Lord of the Rings”? Where they would enjoy debating the fine points of early modern history? Or accept my desire to spend weekends not partying but watching Netflix in pajamas?

Intern Meredith Carroll (Nate Guidry/Post-Gazette)

Meredith Carroll

Advertise with us

Fast-forward a couple years, and a lot has changed. For one, I’ve become a tour guide myself at my chosen school, Grinnell College in Iowa. Showing prospective students and their parents around campus prompts me to look at my experience through other people’s eyes — and reflect on my own college search process.

First things first: Practice helps. The first tour you take will probably be overwhelming. If you’re anything like I was, so will the second and third. But after a while, you internalize the template. You get better at noticing similarities: the athletic centers (nearly always newly renovated), the dorm rooms (never smelling entirely pristine), the “quirky” traditions (that often smack just a little of trying too hard). More importantly, you’ll learn to spot the differences that really matter: the one-of-a-kind stories, the spontaneous interactions, the joke that aligns perfectly with your sense of humor.

Second: Even with all that practice, you probably won’t remember everything. And it probably doesn’t matter anyway. Details about meal plans, roommate assignments and course loads matter, but they’re always a phone call or Google search away. A tour, meanwhile, is one of the few chances you get to engage with a student in real life. My favorite tours — the ones I feel truly represent what I love about my school — resemble conversations far more than they do question-and-answer sessions. My second piece of advice to visitors? Think of the tour as a conversation. It may lead to topics you never would have thought to ask about in the first place.

Third: Don’t obsess over the perfect fit. It’s not that fit is a baseless concern. If you’re devoted to baseball, chances are you want a school with a good team. If you dream of producing musicals, find a school that puts on a lot of them.

But if finding a good fit is necessary, it’s hardly sufficient. For one, college changes you. It may cost obscene sums of money. But (hopefully) college is more than a product you buy. It’s an experience you live through during some of the most formative years of your adult life. One of the reasons it’s so hard to picture exactly what college will feel like is that you’ll be a different person by the time you’re in the middle of it all.

Advertise with us

So when choosing a school, don’t seek the perfect fit for whom you are now. Instead, look for places that reflect who you want to become.

At Grinnell, I continue to geek out about “The Lord of the Rings,” debate historical fine points and enjoy staying in with friends almost every weekend. I’ve also traveled to new cities, taken classes in everything from linear algebra to anthropology and met countless new people as a student reporter and tour guide.

None of these were things I could have imagined doing as a high schooler. But all were things I wanted to become confident and competent enough to pursue. Five-plus years after that hectic first tour, I know I made the right decisions.

Meredith Carroll of Grayslake, Ill., who was a Post-Gazette summer intern, is a senior majoring in history at Grinnell College. She can be reached at localnews@post-gazette.com.