A citizens group has offered some recommendations to the financially ailing Penn Hills School District.

The Citizens Transparency Committee, an ad hoc group formed by taxpayers to examine the district’s financial records, presented the school board with a report of its findings Monday night. Robert Larko, who heads the committee, said it focused on two areas: construction costs — specifically Act 34 state reimbursement for the new high school and elementary school buildings — and the cost of the student transportation contract.

“We are matching past financial reports to Act 34 reports to see if [the school district] did what we said we would do and if Act 34 performed as it should have in terms of reimbursements,” said Mr. Larko, who is vice president and finance manager/controller for PNC Bank and served as chairman of the school district’s tax study commission in 2006-07.

“Our first deep dive on an expense line item was the transportation budget since it was over budget in the first year of a new contract. Transportation was over budget by $2.4 million in 2014‐15. It appears that the budgeted amount of $3.5 million was about $1.1 million under the annual contract amount of $4.6 million, but the annual contract also did not include state-required monitors, excess hours charges or extra buses.”

Advertise with us

According to Mr. Larko, one monthly invoice showed the cost for bus monitors at $50,000, excess hours at $13,000 and the charge for extra buses at $96,000. He said that 10 months of similar charges could amount to the budget shortfall in transportation.

He said other factors that played a role in the transportation budget problems were the necessity of having staff learn new software and what he said was incorrect information about starting and ending times for schools, student rosters and estimates of the time it takes students to get on or off the buses.

“We recommend that the district consider a succession plan to ensure a seamless transition if there is turnover in department personnel and to provide employees with development opportunities to further their careers,” he said. “We recommend that buses run routes at more than one school to minimize extra bus charges; for example, high school buses also run the elementary routes. Any extra hours that would be incurred would be minimal compared to an extra bus charge.”

Mr. Larko recommended that the district do an internal control audit in addition to the financial audit announced by state Auditor General Eugene DePasquale. Mr. Depasquale was requested to review the school district’s financial situation by state Rep. Tony DeLuca, D-Penn Hills, in April after the district revealed it had an $8.9 million deficit and expected an additional $10 million shortfall for the coming year.

Nancy Hines, who was named acting superintendent in February and became superintendent in June, indicated in a statement last week that she welcomes the state audit and will cooperate. On Monday, she noted how difficult the situation has been for her and her staff.

Advertise with us

“This is the most somber start of my career. I see disappointment, anger and grief on the faces of my staff,” Ms. Hines told the audience.” We are in this situation because prior boards and administrations did not make the tough decisions. But we are where we are. We are gravely injured and limping.”

She referred to the district’s latest downgrade to B3 by Moody’s credit rating agency.

Ms. Hines said in spite of the pressure to slash expenses, the district is resolved to stay educationally competitive. “I will not incite an academic crisis in the face of a financial crisis,” she said.

The next board meeting will be held at 7 p.m. Sept. 28 in the board room at Linton Middle School, 250 Aster St.

In addition to Mr. Larko, the members of the Citizens Transparency Committee are John Dugan, Hope Vales, Jim Stuckman and Judy Shopp.The school board sponsor is board President Denise Graham-Shealey.

Advertise with us

Anyone interested in joining the committee can contact one of the members or go to the committee’s Facebook page.

Tim Means, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.