The way state Auditor General Eugene DePasquale sees it, officials in the Penn Hills School District either knew they were repeatedly overspending their budget and ignored the fact or they were so incompetent they didn’t know they were digging themselves into an $18 million hole.

Either way, his audit staff is set to find the answer as it begins its probe of the district’s finances next week.

The audit was requested in April by state Rep. Tony DeLuca, D-Penn Hills, shortly after the district revealed it had an $8.9 million deficit and expected an additional $10 million shortfall for the coming year.

“If you are the federal government, $18 million isn’t a lot of money. But if you are a school district of this size, that’s an extraordinary amount,” Mr. DePasquale said. “It’s hard to imagine a scenario where they didn’t know some of this was happening.”

Advertise with us

Penn Hills superintendent Nancy Hines said in a statement: “We welcome the visit and will cooperate in any and every way. We view it as good news that will help close out discovery and aid in recovery efforts.”

Since April, the school board has faced heavy questioning from residents and former board members over how it did not foresee the financial disaster.

A review of independent audits of the district by the Post-Gazette has shown a widening gap between revenues and expenses beginning in 2011-12, when the district withdrew $958,692 from a $4.65 million fund balance. The district then took $3.56 million from the fund balance in 2012-13, leaving $126,555.

Board members have said they were misled about the state of the district’s finances. Ms. Hines said the board did not find out about the district’s deficit until shortly before its April 6 meeting.

But Richard Liberto, the district’s business manager who was placed on leave in March, has maintained that he warned district officials about financial problems. “I’ve always expressed to them in my public finance committee meetings, in my emails, in my weekly reports, that the district is suffering,” Mr. Liberto said during a May interview.

Advertise with us

In June the board approved a $97 million budget that included a 0.65-mill tax increase and a $12 million short-term loan and some staff cuts. The loan must be paid back within 90 days.

The board’s long-term plan for the debt is to sell $18 million in bonds and it is in the process of trying to do so, even though it has a poor bond rating. It received permission from Common Pleas Court in April to seek the financing.

Mr. DePasquale said he initially planned to wait until his office was finished in mid-November with its current audit of the Pittsburgh Public Schools before starting the Penn Hills audit. However, he said, he was getting pressure from the public to start the Penn Hills audit sooner.

He expects the audit, which will cover the period of July 1, 2012, through June 30, 2015, to last at least through next spring.

Among the things it will examine is whether the district adequately monitors its credit and debit cards for unauthorized or personal use. Mr. DePasquale said he had no information indicating that credit cards were misused but that the large deficit gives him “sufficient reason to be concerned they did not” monitor them properly.

Advertise with us

The audit also will evaluate the district’s financial position and determine if it complies with the Public School Code, which prohibits deficit fund balances and overspending the district’s budget.

The district’s transportation contract was over budget by $4 million during the 2014-15 school year. It is currently trying to renegotiate it.

Mary Niederberger: mniederberger@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1590.