The Greater Latrobe School District has agreed to build a new elementary school, concluding more than a year of discussion on whether to renovate or replace a longstanding one that has not seen major repairs in 20 years.
The decision to spend nearly $30 million to replace Latrobe Elementary School has proved somewhat controversial, coming a year or so after the opening of a multimillion-dollar sports complex.
But it is much needed, said Rhonda Laughlin, school board president. Calling it a prudent step, she said, “We have to look 15 to 20 years from now.”
School directors informally agreed last month on a recommendation to build the elementary school on part of the Old Athletic Field, across Lincoln Avenue from the district administration building.
It is expected to cost $28.7 million, which the district would finance at least partly by issuing bonds. It also would apply for state funding for school construction.
The district is already facing some $22 million in debt, business manager Dan Watson said.
The board still must make further decisions that involve acquiring the land, which Latrobe owns, and the fate of the existing Ligonier Street school building, Ms. Laughlin said. She added that construction is not expected to begin for at least a year.
Latrobe Elementary has remained a focal point since its roof started leaking about a year and a half ago, prompting the district to spend tens of thousands of dollars on repairs last summer in what Ms. Laughlin called “a little more than an emergency.”
In response, the district hired an architecture firm to conduct a feasibility study on renovating the four-story school building, whose original part was built in the 1910s and served as the district’s first high school. The study by Axis Architecture found that renovating the building would cost $23.1 million.
The new school would stretch two stories, featuring wings of classrooms surrounding common areas such as a cafeteria and a library, according to a plan drawn up by the firm.
The district comprises five school buildings, including three elementaries. Of those, Latrobe Elementary is the biggest, housing a little more than 800 students in grades K-6.
The decision to build a new school has drawn some criticism largely because it comes after the district spent roughly $9 million to build the multipurpose sports complex that opened for the 2014-15 school year and that features a football and soccer stadium that seats some 2,000 people. That money also went toward renovations, including to the facade and hallways of the junior high school, Ms. Laughlin said.
Given that Latrobe Elementary has not undergone a major renovation since the early 1990s, it seems like the district “is turning its back on more serious matters,” said Paul Upson, a retired longtime consultant who lives in Latrobe and who ran unsuccessfully for a seat on the school board in 2013.
Referring to the multipurpose complex, he suggested that it is superfluous, calling it a “Taj Mahal.”
School officials, on the other hand, insist that it was necessary, saying the fields that once were regularly used by the high school’s more than two dozen sports teams had seen their share of wear and tear.
“We had to do something,” athletic director Mark Mears said of building the complex.
The decision to build the new school also comes less than two months after school directors voted to raise property taxes, by 1 mill, marking the fifth consecutive year the district has done so.
Asked why the district built the sports complex before fully addressing issues with the elementary school, Ms. Laughlin, the board president, suggested that financial support for the complex was readily available, saying the financing of the two projects is “not comparable.”
In addition to issuing bonds, the district is paying for the complex with donations from the Greater Latrobe Partners in Education Foundation, which has raised nearly $5 million since it was created in early 2013. Among the donations were personal funds from school administrators and directors, she said.
As for the tax increases, Ms. Laughlin attributed them entirely to increasing contributions to the Public School Employees’ Retirement System.
Even so, Mr. Upson countered that the district should have paid closer attention to the condition of Latrobe Elementary.
“This is not something that happened overnight,” he said.
Jake Flannick, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.