Nearly five years after the West Jefferson Hills school board fired former Superintendent Terry Kinavey, Common Pleas Judge Alan Hertzberg has affirmed the board’s actions.

The process that led to Mrs. Kinavey’s undoing started with raucous school board meetings in August 2009 and was followed by a tense public termination hearing held in two sessions, each spanning several months.

But the final court action, in which Judge Hertzberg found the school board’s actions were supported by “substantial evidence” was filed quietly on June 5.

“Obviously this has been a very long process and we are pleased that it got to this point,” said West Jefferson solicitor Ira Weiss.

Advertise with us

Mrs. Kinavey’s attorney Ernest DeHaas has filed an appeal in Commonwealth Court.

He had no comment on Judge Hertzberg’s ruling other than to say his appeal makes the same arguments as were made to the lower court -- that Mrs, Kinavey’s constitutional rights were violated and that the board’s decision was not based on substantial evidence.

Mrs. Kinavey was placed on administrative leave in September 2009 and fired a year later The board cited neglect of duty and immorality for the firing. Those causes are among the specific reasons for firing a superintendent based on the state school code.

The charges stemmed from her actions surrounding the hiring of Jefferson resident Denise Breisinger as a reading and English teacher at Thomas Jefferson High School and allegations that Mrs. Kinavey plagiarized letters she sent to students, staff and parents for the beginning of the 2009 school year and in a column she submitted for the district newsletter.

A district investigation and testimony at her termination hearing disclosed that Mrs. Kinavey removed Mrs. Breisinger’s name from a draft agenda without the board’s knowledge in August 2009 after Mrs. Breisinger had gone through the interview process along with other candidates and was the sole remaining candidate.

Advertise with us

Large crowds of residents protesting the move showed up at the August school board meetings, catching the board off guard and prompting an investigation into the situation.

Following the initial investigation, Mrs. Kinavey was placed on paid leave in September 2009 at the same meeting the board hired Mrs. Breisinger.

In November 2009, after a more extensive internal investigation, Mrs. Kinavey was suspended without pay and charged with incompetence, neglect of duty, intemperance and immorality.

Mrs. Kinavey chose to have a public termination hearing and the initial phase stretched through 15 sessions over five months ending in May 2010. The board voted to fire her in September 2010, issuing a 63-page document called “Findings of Fact” which supported its decision.

Mrs. Kinavey appealed the decision to Common Pleas Court, where Judge Hertzberg ordered the case to be remanded to the district for a full and complete review. That included a reopening of the hearing with an additional seven hearing sessions held from October 2012 to May 2013.

Advertise with us

During the initial years of the legal proceedings involving Mrs. Kinavey, the district went through four interim superintendents until May 2013 when it hired Michael Panza as its permanent superintendent, awarding him a five-year contract.

In August 2013, the board adopted a resolution reaffirming its previous findings that it had legitimate grounds to dismiss her.

Judge Hertzberg, in his June decision, cited some of the facts presented in the district’s case and concluded that the district “created a full and complete record, therefore; I am bound to uphold any adjudication supported by substantial evidence.”

Mary Niederberger: mniederberger@post-gazette.com.