The state Senate Education Committee today voted out of committee legislation that proposes that the state takes over some schools that consistently do poorly.

The bill, called the Educational Opportunity and Accountability Act, calls for transferring the lowest-performing schools to a new Achievement School District. The district would have an executive director and a board comprising appointees by the governor and legislators.

In an amendment approved by the committee, a community advisory committee would be established, made up by three parents of students attending what would be called an intervention school and three residents of the area served by the intervention school.

The proposal also would permit the lowest-performing charter schools to be closed without an appeal to the state Charter School Appeal Board.

Advertise with us

The Achievement School District also could convert a building to a charter school or authorize new schools in neighborhoods where the schools perform in the bottom 1 percent.

In a news release in April, Sen. Lloyd Smucker, R-Lancaster, who sponsored the bill, said, "We need to support these schools and their students, to ensure that they can turn themselves around, before these children fall further and further behind."

An analysis of the bill released by the Education Law Center last month said that 146 schools would become eligible, of which 90 already are under state operation in some manner. It said that 31 schools are brick-and-mortar charter schools.

After the vote, the Pennsylvania State Education Association issued a news release in which president Mike Crossey said, "This bill reads like a laundry list of failed ideas. From state takeovers, to staff cuts, to shutting down schools, all of these ideas have been tried before and they're now piled on the ash heap of history.

"What we need to do is resolve the school funding crisis, fund our schools properly, give every student the tools they need to learn and make sure every educator has the resources they need to teach."

Advertise with us

Sen. Vincent Hughes, D-Philadelphia, next week plans to introduce alternative legislation that would call for reducing class size, providing more instruction time and offering more social services.

Education writer Eleanor Chute: echute@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1955.