Members of the East Allegheny teachers’ union rejected a non-binding arbitration proposal last week from a neutral arbitrator who took almost four months to prepare it.
Cheryl Ihnat, president of East Allegheny Education Association, the teachers’ union, wrote in a press release, “We are disappointed in the determination and continue to believe that the association’s final best offer is very fair to the district, the membership and the community. The association has acknowledged that the district has financial concerns, and teachers have been willing to share the burden.”
William J. Miller Jr., the arbitrator, took testimony and information from the union and the district during a hearing on January 27 on both sides’ proposals for a new teachers’ contract.
He also compared the district’s and teachers’ final best contract proposals line by line, and kept accepting input for his recommendation until April 26.
Eric Elliot, representing East Allegheny Education Association, and Michael Palombo, representing the district, also served on the arbitration panel.
Prior to the teachers’ vote last week, East Allegheny school board voted 8 to 0 to accept Mr. Miller’s recommendations, which favored the district in terms of salary and benefits, and favored the teachers in terms of their desire to influence class sizes.
School Director Stephen Volpe was absent.
Mr. Miller’s report said that though setting class size “is a managerial prerogative,” the teachers and district agree to meet during the first month of each academic year to review and address class sizes, and to find cost-neutral ways to address class size concerns “that a class is too large to foster effective teaching and learning,” among other points.
Throughout the negotiations, school directors have said they are unwilling to raise taxes again on financially strapped district families with a median household income of $25,000 to give the teachers a raise.
According to the district’s website, the district has 17 teachers who earn $92,468.49 apiece, and an average teacher salary of $64,045.30.
Mrs. Ihnat said she doesn’t think it will be necessary to raise taxes, only to examine the budget and use district money more prudently. She said she could not suggest which area of the budget the teachers’ raises should come from.
Earlier, district business manager Toni Valicenti said that the district’s deficit increased from $1,158,236 on July 1, 2013, to $2,433,696 by June 30, 2014.
In the section of Mr. Miller’s proposal about salary and benefits, he wrote, “a careful review of the applicable district finances clearly establishes a significant financial hardship in meeting its financial obligations.”
Mrs. Ihnat said the teachers only want what is fair and equal. Shortly before the teachers’ contract expired in June 2012, district administrators signed a five-year contract that included a wage freeze the first year, and salary increases of $2,500 each of the remaining four years of the contract, she said.
The teachers’ press release said the arbitrator’s recommendation conflicts with a fact-finder’s report done in 2012 by Robert Gifford that the teachers accepted and the school board rejected.
School Director Frederick Miller said Mr. Palombo asked the teachers to put a new proposal on the table for discussion after they voted to reject arbitrator William Miller’s recommendations.
In the teachers’ press release, Mrs. Ihnat said she can’t say whether the teachers will go on strike a second time this year.
“It is a decision that the team does not take lightly,” she wrote.
The teachers and district representatives are both willing to continue to negotiate, Frederick Miller said.
“The focus should be on the current situation, not on the fact-finder’s report about three years old,” he said.
“Hopefully we can sit down and work this out and come to an agreement,” Mrs. Ihnat said.
Fredrick Miller said he is open to the two sides coming to an agreement with some small adjustments.
Anne Cloonan, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.