Flaws in screening employees who work with children have been found at another higher education institution in Pennsylvania — this time the University of Pittsburgh — and a state official said Thursday it should serve as a wake-up call.
State Auditor General Eugene DePasquale said that for years, Pitt did not adequately ensure that athletic camp and campus employees working with minors during Pitt-hosted events had undergone required criminal background checks.
In releasing a performance audit, Mr. DePasquale also said Pitt’s controls were insufficient to ensure that procurement card transactions and approvals were consistent with university policy. Also, in at least one instance, Pitt did not adequately justify a sole-source contract and sometimes “did not always document that prices paid for directed or sole-source contracts were reasonable.”
Those are among eight findings in an audit that covered the period of July 1, 2010, to June 30, 2013. Five findings were negative and two were positive, including a determination that Pitt was in compliance with National Collegiate Athletic Association bylaws covering athlete eligibility and financial aid. In one case, Pitt did not provide enough information for a finding to be reached.
At a news conference, Mr. DePasquale said there was no indication any child was harmed and that the audit also showed that Pitt has strengthened procedures. “I want to commend the [university] for where they are on this,” he noted.
Still, he said, the audit “is what it is” and the fact that other campuses in Pennsylvania, including Edinboro, California and Cheyney universities, were found by him to have similar screening flaws should be a general warning to schools. “We are going to be looking,” he said.
Read More
On the youth athletic camps, the audit found that prior to January 2012, Pitt “exercised no oversight and did not have policies in place to require coaches, who operated youth athletic camps on university property, to obtain background checks from their employees and volunteers.’’
The school “placed the oversight and policing of the summer youth athletic camps on coaches,” who were not required to sign contracts with Pitt, although they were on Pitt property and used campus facilities, according to the audit.
By summer 2012, Pitt used contracts with coaches but “did not verify” that coaches working as contractors had obtained background checks from employees and volunteers. Sixty-one youth athletic camps were hosted by coaches between January 2012 and June 30, 2013, the audit said.
Mr. DePasquale also found similar lack of oversight at educational camps and other events for minors hosted by various departments at Pitt.
Since November 2011, the Jerry Sandusky child sex abuse scandal at Penn State University heightened concern about background screening. Asked why Pitt still was not adequately ensuring background checks months later at these events, officials said Pitt actually did more than the law required in some areas of criminal checks but took to heart the auditor general’s call to verify checks, even at non-Pitt-sponsored events.
“We saw the issue in no small part due to the auditor general,” said P. Jerome Richey, senior vice chancellor and chief legal officer at Pitt. “And we responded to it … this is a rapidly evolving area.”
On procurement cards, the auditor general also found problems. Pitt said it did, too, and had already begun corrective actions.
“Our review of ... 25 cardholders and 208 procurement card purchases disclosed 59 purchases or 28 percent of the transactions ... violated the university’s procurement card policies,’’ the audit stated.
One cardholder, since terminated, used a card to make six personal purchases, and another split a $13,379 purchase into multiple transactions to circumvent a $2,000 transaction limit.
The audit noted another employee was accused by police of making 114 unauthorized purchases totaling $31,572 between August 2012 and January 2014. Brenda Pecora, 42, of North Huntingdon, entered an accelerated rehabilitative disposition program in November, giving her 15 months to complete 200 hours of community service to have the charge against her withdrawn, according to Allegheny County court records.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.