HARRISBURG — Pennsylvania’s academic standards and end-of-course high school examinations are in place. But not, if some legislators have their way, for good.
The House Education Committee on Thursday heard testimony on two proposals that could affect what the state’s public school students are required to learn.
One, from Rep. Mike Tobash, R-Schuylkill, would eliminate the state requirement that the Keystone exams in algebra 1, literature and biology become a graduation prerequisite (though one with exemptions) for the class of 2017 and cease the development of the exams for other subject areas.
The other bill, from Rep. Seth Grove, R-York, would create a commission to review Pennsylvania’s academic standards, which are themselves the product of revision after opposition to the state’s adoption of the Common Core standards.
Representatives of educators cautioned committee members that further changes to the standards would leave schools uncertain about their academic aims. Although the Pennsylvania Association of School Administrators supports examining the academic objectives, Lee Ann Wentzel, superintendent of the Ridley School District in Delaware County, also urged caution, saying that today’s high school juniors have been taught and assessed under three sets of state standards.
“Students, parents, teachers and schools are suffering from a bad case of state policy whiplash,” she said.
An official with the Pennsylvania State Education Association, the state’s largest teachers union, said Pennsylvania should focus on implementing the standards it already has.
“Convening a commission to consider changing Pennsylvania’s standards again sends a clear message to districts to stop and wait,” said PSEA vice president Jerry Oleksiak. “Educators can’t afford to engage in a process of continual curricular redesign. They can’t keep trying to hit a moving target.”
Both the administrators and teachers organizations support dropping the Keystone exams as a state requirement for graduation.
But David Patti, president and CEO of the Pennsylvania Business Council, cautioned that without the graduation requirement, students would not have “skin in the game” in taking the tests, raising questions of how schools can determine if students are ready for advanced study and how teachers and schools can be fairly evaluated.
After the hearing, Chairman Stan Saylor said he would consult with committee members before deciding whether they would move forward with a vote on the bills.
In the Senate, Sen. Andy Dinniman, D-Chester, has proposed scrapping the use of the Keystone exams as a graduation requirement on the grounds that there is too great a disparity in financial resources among the state’s public schools for high-stakes testing to be fair.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.