Three months after it was assembled and about two months before it is supposed to deliver a report on public education in Pittsburgh, Mayor Bill Peduto’s education task force is still searching for its mission as it prepares for its third meeting tonight.
Curtiss Porter, the mayor’s chief education and neighborhood reinvestment officer, said the 21-member task force, which the mayor and city council convened to address school closings and make recommendations on improving the school system, is still trying to find its footing. But Mr. Porter noted that he expects the collaboration among city politicians, teachers, parents, nonprofits and school board members, among others, to be a positive step forward.
“The engagement and participation has been high,” said Mr. Porter, who is running the group with Cosette Grant-Overton, the mayor’s manager of educational policy and workforce development. “It would be fair to say there also may be some measured but hopeful skepticism.”
Some task force members have privately complained about what they characterized as a lack of focus and direction since the panel’s first meeting in June. Others have been less guarded in their assessments.
Neither of the task force’s meetings have been “particularly productive,” said city Controller Michael Lamb, a task force member.
“The task force has yet to develop any objectives other than to say that nobody wants to see further school closures. It is arguable as to whether that is due to a lack of leadership from the mayor’s office or the constraints of the ordinance, but to this point the task force has lacked the proper focus to make it a worthwhile endeavor,” Mr. Lamb said.
Read More
“I am not hopeful that there will be any meaningful recommendations other than the obvious suggestion that the city and school district should work to build a better relationship, communicate more and work better together.”
Four task force meetings were scheduled between June 16 and July 22, but only two took place — both of them in private. The task force is scheduled to meet tonight — also in private. Tim McNulty, spokesman for the mayor, said the final meeting on Oct. 21 will be open to the public.
About a year ago, city council passed a resolution establishing the Public Schools Task Force, directing the panel to publish a report by Sept. 1 and implement the recommendations before Dec. 31.
The report deadline later was extended to Dec. 1, with implementation still set for the end of that month, but with schools superintendent Linda Lane saying no new school closings were contemplated, the task force had to come up with a “refocusing of effort,” Mr. Porter said, acknowledging that has led to a degree of frustration.
“Yes, from time to time individuals would have expressed frustration, and the same individuals had hopeful expressions as we continued through the process,” he said.
That the city and school officials are at the same table to improve public education is seen as a success in its own right.
“The fact of the matter is, there’s such a wide swath of goals and objectives in the city of Pittsburgh, it’s hard to decide what the focus should be,” said city Councilwoman Natalia Rudiak, who is on the task force.
“That being said, I think one of the benefits of having the task force is that, for the first time in many years, you have school board members sitting alongside city council members and parents and teachers in a forum that hasn’t been available before. I think that’s beneficial in terms of building trust between the city and the school board [that] can translate into benefits for the community.”
In June, Mr. Peduto’s office named the members and announced that Preston Green, professor of urban education at the University of Connecticut’s Neag School of Education and a professor of educational leadership and law at the University of Connecticut, would be task force mediator. He was to have been paid as much as $20,000, including travel and expenses but lasted one meeting and collected one payment for about $4,700, according to city records.
“The task force decided after the first session that his role was not needed, and the council resolution creating the task force was amended to reflect that. … Dr. Porter and Dr. Grant-Overton are leading the discussions,” Mr. McNulty said.
Mr. Green said, “It just made sense really to go another direction. I really don’t want to go into detail as to all that went down.”
Brian Brown, organizer for the Youth Organizing Program of the Hill District Consensus Group and a task force member, considers the group to be making progress.
“I think we’re trying to figure out what are we going to be overall focusing on,” he said. “I just think we are a group of people who really are passionate about education, and we’re trying our best to actually address the issues that are affecting our public school system.”
Regina Holley, one of two school board members on the task force, said the group is “sincere about the work that we want to do,” though she would not discuss specifics.
“We’re just still trying to work on some issues. They’re not ready to talk about that as of yet. … I’m not at liberty to talk to you about what we’re doing right now,” she said.
Mr. Porter said he hopes the final report will contain “action items” but would not discuss specifics. He said the task force should be best understood as a bridge-building exercise between city government and the school system.
“If we assume that both parties are interested in that positive outcome then I think the city can be a really strong partner with the board of education in achieving those aims,” he said.
Robert Zullo: rzullo@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909. Twitter: @rczullo. Eleanor Chute: echute@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1955. Twitter: @Eleanor_Chute.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.