Angelo Armenti Jr.'s 20-year career as head of California University of Pennsylvania was marked by a dramatic increase in enrollment, upgraded facilities, a higher profile for the school across the state and nationally recognized sports teams.
Mr. Armenti "transformed our campus" and "guided Cal U's growth into a world-class institution that will stand as a lasting legacy to his leadership and vision," Robert Irey, chairman of the council of trustees, said of the former president fired Wednesday night.
But that leadership was also plagued by controversies over grading, faculty firings, costly lawsuits and complaints from professors about cuts to academic programs and overspending in other areas, including a new $59 million convocation center.
Some faculty members also had long complained that they worked at the "Wal-Mart of academia" because they said Mr. Armenti viewed students as paying customers and, as such, backed them in any dispute with their instructors.
"Finally," was the reaction of Bill Parnell, the former chairman of the graduate department of counselor education, who was fired by Mr. Armenti in 1996. "This is long overdue."
Mr. Parnell, a second-generation alumnus of Cal U who won a $235,000 settlement from the school over his termination, said he had never seen another university president survive two no-confidence votes from the faculty, as occurred with Mr. Armenti after he fired Mr. Parnell and three other professors in the 1990s.
"For whatever reason, the trustees ... never chose to take what many faculty and students and former students feel is an action that should have been taken long ago," he said.
Phillip Hayes, who retired in 1999 after serving as dean of students and university judicial officer, had been demoted by Mr. Armenti, who also fired Mr. Hayes' son-in-law.
Although he was tempted to gloat over the fallen, Mr. Hayes said "it's distressing when anyone loses his job. He couldn't keep his spending under control. That's what did it."
Although some regard Mr. Armenti as a visionary, his vision allowed no questions or input from others, Mr. Hayes said.
"He's not one who will sit and listen," he said. "He'd rather be talking."
Mr. Armenti, 72, has most recently been under attack by students and professors who say academics at the school have declined because of the debt that Cal U has taken on to pay for a campuswide building boom.
Some programs have been eliminated and managers furloughed to save money while such projects as the convocation center and other building projects have gobbled up funds.
The 6,000-seat center, the largest between Pittsburgh and Morgantown, W.Va., has been a particular sore point. Critics say it has produced just $11,000 in revenue since it opened last year, but it needs $1.1 million to operate.
Complaints about spending led the State System of Higher Education to audit the school earlier this year. Members of the faculty union also had asked the chancellor of the state system to intervene.
Mr. Armenti was as polarizing in the borough of California as he was on campus.
Some community and business leaders declined to discuss him on the record Thursday, saying that either a positive or a negative comment would upset some local families. The university, they all agreed, is vital to California, whose small downtown retains antiquarian charm but has never recovered from the steel industry bust of the 1970s.
"His leadership over 20 years is very evident. He took an old state college and turned it into a university. He made it look like a real campus, which is important if you're trying to attract students," said state Sen. Richard Kasunic, D-Dunbar.
"He showed he was a visionary and a great leader. I'm saddened by what has transpired. I have nothing but the highest regard and respect for what he accomplished and for him."
Michael Sears, principal of the California Area Elementary School and a member of the borough planning commission, admired Mr. Armenti for his commitment to reviving the campus. His own task on the planning commission has been to develop a community master plan for creating continuity between the showplace campus and what is now a down-at-the-heels downtown. Mr. Sears said he was disappointed at Mr. Armenti's departure, but believed he had left a legacy that the borough can build on.
"He developed a vision for what the university should strive for, and he's done a remarkable job in achieving it," Mr. Sears said.
The Rev. Candace Cook, pastor of the First Presbyterian Church of California, was impressed with his efforts to build a good relationship with the wider community. She came to California 21/2 years ago and had lived in other college towns where there was open hostility between community and campus. California, she said, isn't like that.
"I've been really impressed with him," she said of Mr. Armenti. "He worked hard to establish relationships here."
She admired the way that his wife, Barbara, got involved with local projects, especially a day care center that was established primarily to care for the children of students.
"They seem to have really embraced the community," Rev. Cook said.
Mr. Armenti came to Cal U from Villanova in 1992 with the goal of overcoming small-town southwestern Pennsylvania demographics -- a graying population and an exodus of young people -- and boosting enrollment with aggressive tactics.
During his first four years on the job, enrollment declined by 800 students and reached a low of 5,600 in 1996. Now it stands at more than 8,500.
Under Mr. Armenti, the school became the first of the 14 state universities to eliminate traditional dorms, investing $125 million to replace old facilities with modern, suite-style apartments.
Cal U also beefed up its marketing campaign under Mr. Armenti and targeted its recruiting in the eastern part of the state, including Philadelphia, and in towns along the Pennsylvania Turnpike.
In addition, the school started Cal U Global Online, an Internet-based program with 27 offerings that accounted for half of the school's growth by tapping working adults and military personnel.
Mr. Armenti was responsible for many of the positive changes, the school said. Under his tenure, according to school figures, applications have increased 90 percent, average SAT scores have increased by 113 points and four-year graduation rates have increased by 94 percent. New academic programs have also been started, such as master's programs in social work, teaching and multimedia technology as well as programs in physical therapy, sports management, graphic design and other disciplines.
Mr. Armenti also oversaw a boost in the school's athletic programs. He pushed for the creation of an Athletic Hall of Fame, the completion of a $13 million capital campaign and a second capital campaign on target to reach its $35 million goal.
Despite such successes, Mr. Armenti's leadership was marred in the 1990s by a series of faculty firings that ultimately cost state taxpayers more than $1.5 million in settlements, legal fees and back wages.
Mr. Armenti fired three professors and demoted a dean after students complained of sexual harassment. All four were ultimately cleared of any wrongdoing and reinstated.
The faculty union president, who backed the fired professors, contended that the sexual harassment charges were bogus and merely a means for Mr. Armenti to get rid of tenured professors with whom he had clashed.
Grading disputes had been an issue several times under Mr. Armenti.
In 1997, two English professors who failed the same student in American literature said Mr. Armenti changed the student's grade to "P" for pass. In another grading controversy, the university ended up paying $235,000 to settle a suit brought by Mr. Parnell, whom Mr. Armenti fired in 1996 after accusing him of retaliating against a student by flunking her.
An arbitrator ruled that Mr. Parnell gave the student the grade she deserved and reinstated him. He later sued and received the settlement.
The cases involving the professors angered the faculty, leading to the two no-confidence votes. Many said academic integrity on campus had eroded under Mr. Armenti because he wanted to appease students to keep enrollment high.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.