By 10:55 a.m. Thursday the students in Robert Morris University's Survey of Mass Communication class were all thumbs.
Free to text, Tweet, Pin or check their Facebook accounts after 48 hours of social media abstinence, they were given five minutes to catch up.
Even professor Yvonne Bland, who maintains an active presence in the online virtual world, "Second Life," was eager to read her 33 instant messages.
"Look at this -- I've had two missed calls in the five minutes since class began," she said.
The point of the two-day social media shutdown was not to prove that silence is golden, or that technology is necessarily disrupting our traditional communications skills.
"The goal of this class is to promote media literacy, and I want to make the students build an awareness to how often they turn to their phones," Ms. Bland said.
It's not a novel idea; at Bates College in Maine in November, more than 300 students and staff pledged to abstain from Facebook and texting, some for a day, some for a week.
Emily Wright-Magoon, Bates associate multi-faith chaplain, said the event was planned in conjunction with a visit from Scott Belsky, CEO of Behance, which provides production services for people in creative businesses.
Mr. Belsky spoke about "constant connectivity," which he said "threatens both your quality of life and your ability to make an impact on what matters most to you."
Today's youth -- and to a less extent, their elders -- often engage in what Mr. Belsky calls "insecurity work," or compulsive checking of social media. "We want to know that our family and friends are there for us," he said in his November lecture.
Social media "is like the oxygen around us: we are no longer aware of it in our daily lives," Ms. Bland said.
No surprise then, that at least half of the 32 class members reported feeling "terribly" stressed when deprived of it. Ms. Bland made it clear at the start of the assignment that participation was optional, and that use of smartphones and computers was not banned for school- or work-related use.
Students were charged with the charmingly retro task of writing about their experiences in traditional college "blue books." They were also to participate in a high-tech, in-class survey that would involve texting their reactions to questions such as "Did your abstinence from social networking annoy or stress your family and friends?"
In theory, voting by text would provide real-time survey results. But the program refused to update. Score one for paper and pen.
"I could just cry," Ms. Bland said. "But fortunately, I come from a generation that doesn't need technology, so let's continue the discussion [without it]."
Some of the adjectives they used to describe the assignment were "confined," "bored," "bittersweet," "peaceful," "strangely good" and "eye-opening."
Although the survey included a "waste of time" option, no one chose it.
Their experiences ranged from frustrating to funny. Joel Desueza said "I used a regular phone for the first time in years. I said to my mom 'Don't we have a phone somewhere?' "
Shane Spirik wanted to tell her mother about the commencement cap and gown that arrived Tuesday but couldn't text her. So she drove to Cecil Township and showed her. Lisa Folli said she was "angry at first" but then realized that most of her communications with friends involved never actually looking them in the eye.
That made her pause for consideration.
"We give up some of that warmth that the world tells us we are giving up, and we had just pooh-poohed," Ms. Bland said of Ms. Folli's comment.
Lindsay Casile, who said she rarely uses Facebook, was at a Penguins game Tuesday night, sitting right behind the visitors bench. She snapped photos and was just about to post them when she realized she couldn't.
"I thought, 'Are you kidding me?' "
Being incommunicado wasn't necessarily a bad thing for some of the students. Megan Conlon was only half joking when she said it was a relief not to have to answer the texts of her sister, a bride-to-be who doesn't hesitate to contact her maid of honor with wedding details.
"I was, like, 'Ha ha, I really don't have to answer you,' " Ms. Conlon said.
Then there was Alan Buehler, who called the break from social media "relieving." He, as did most of the others, cheated a couple of times, although his usual mode of conversation is limited to texting anyway.
"[Avoiding] Facebook was no problem, since I don't have a smartphone," he said, holding up an old-school clamshell cell. "It still flips!" His classmates regarded the phone as one might some oversized, exotic insect.
Before the class began its two-day blackout, Ms. Bland speculated there might be a lot of grumpy participants, their professor among them.
"My family is just terrified of what my mood is going to be like on Wednesday. I not only use my phone for multiple purposes, I have multiple emails, I've got Facebook, Twitter, texting and I use two or three different IM's.
"I'm also a rabid fan of Second Life."
Yet by Thursday morning, all was well. Ms. Bland handed out chocolates and candy at the start of class, before the ceremonial powering up of cell phones.
"I am starving for social interaction, aren't you guys?" she said.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.