A federal judge has thrown out a civil rights lawsuit filed by two key players in a master's degree scandal at West Virginia University, ruling that the complaint was filed after the two-year statute of limitations.

The complaint by former WVU business school dean R. Stephen Sears and marketing professor Cyril Logar was filed in December 2010 against the university's board of governors and various school officials. It alleged that academic misconduct proceedings initiated against them in the summer of 2008 were tainted by conflicts of interest.

The two men sought damages for harm done to their reputations.

"We are obviously disappointed in the court's decision," said Thomas Clare of Kirkland & Ellis in Washington, D.C., an attorney for Mr. Sears. "We are seriously considering an appeal."

Advertise with us

An attorney for Mr. Logar, Robert Ridge of Thorp Reed & Armstrong in Pittsburgh, said he was "confident" his client would appeal.

The order dismissing the case was made late Thursday by West Virginia U.S. District Judge Frederick P. Stamp Jr.

Mr. Sears, who now works in Texas, resigned as business school dean, and Mr. Logar lost his post as associate dean in 2008 after an independent investigative panel convened by WVU found that administrators had falsified student records to back Mylan Inc. executive Heather Bresch's claim that she had earned an MBA degree. Ms. Bresch is the daughter of former West Virginia governor and now-U.S. Sen. Joe Manchin.

The panel's findings also led to the resignations of WVU President Michael Garrison and Provost Gerald Lang.

"We are obviously pleased with the [court's] decision," WVU spokesman John Bolt said Friday.

Advertise with us

He declined to say whether the university would proceed with misconduct hearings, saying such matters were confidential.

In July, the university agreed to drop misconduct charges against Mr. Lang to settle a lawsuit he filed in early 2009 claiming his due process rights were being violated.

As part of the settlement, Mr. Lang, now the university's vice president for research and economic development, signed a statement acknowledging his role in retroactively awarding the degree to Ms. Bresch. The university has declined to release a copy of that statement.

Three other men involved in the matter -- Mr. Garrison's former chief of staff Craig Walker and professors Gerald Blakely and Paul Speaker -- also were facing disciplinary hearings before Mr. Lang's suit effectively stopped the hearings.

A grand jury in West Virginia that investigated the matter in 2008 declined to return criminal indictments. While jury members said "ethical and moral boundaries were violated by all individuals involved," they concluded that their conduct reflected poor judgment and the misapplication of power rather than criminal activity.