As leader of the committee searching for the next president of West Virginia University's flagship campus in Morgantown, Stephen P. Goodwin proudly describes the months-long hunt for candidates as open, transparent and inclusive.
But lately some people in West Virginia, including a federal judge who is a director of the WVU alumni association, have questioned whether politics has tainted the search.
Charleston-based U.S. Circuit Judge Robert B. King wrote a letter to search committee members and others criticizing the selection process, Mr. Goodwin confirmed. The judge's sister, Mary Ellen Mazey, is a dean at WVU and a search committee member.
"I was disappointed in the letter. I was disappointed in its content. He attacks the process and says he questions whether it was a legitimate process," Mr. Goodwin said. "It clearly indicated [the judge thought] the process was flawed and was politically motivated."
Mr. Goodwin, who defended the integrity of the search as did a number of other committee members, said the letter did not mention by name any of the three finalists who are vying to succeed David C. Hardesty Jr. at the helm of WVU, with its $700 million budget and 27,000 students.
Some in the state's news media have cast a skeptical eye on the connections of one candidate: Michael S. Garrison, a Morgantown lawyer with little higher education experience but deep political ties.
A WVU graduate, Oxford University scholar and key aide to a former governor, Mr. Garrison, 38, is competing against two career academics who hold top positions at their universities -- Daniel O. Bernstine, 59, president of Portland State University in Oregon, and M. Duane Nellis, 52, a former arts and sciences dean at WVU and now provost of Kansas State University.
"We are mildly amused at the charade of a process going on at West Virginia University in their latest presidential 'search,' " said an editorial on HuntingtonNews.net, an independent online newspaper.
"The real dilemma for WVU and for the state is that state politics is trumping genuinely distinguished higher education experience as embodied by the other two candidates."
"There is a sense of preordination about the search for David Hardesty's replacement as West Virginia University President. Mike Garrison, everyone wants to tell me, will get the job," Hoppy Kercheval, a radio announcer for the statewide Metronews network, wrote in the Charleston Daily Mail.
An editorial in WVU's student newspaper, The Daily Athenaeum, expressed reservations about all three candidates.
"We know an understanding of West Virginia's political system is necessary for the University's president," the editorial said in its comments on Mr. Garrison. "But we hope he wasn't chosen [as a finalist] primarily because of his political contacts."
Mr. Garrison served as state secretary of the Department of Tax and Revenue in 2001 and chief of staff to former Democratic Gov. Bob Wise from May 2001 to October 2003.
In that position, he would have been involved in the appointment process of five of the 17 members of the WVU Board of Governors, including Mr. Goodwin, the chairman. Board members are appointed by the governor and confirmed by the state Senate.
"The scuttlebutt, what's being discussed, is those board members are in kind of a tough spot because he's the guy who shepherded the board members through the appointment process," said Republican state Sen. Vic Sprouse, whose district includes Charleston.
"Will there be home-cooking by Mike Garrison, who is a very intelligent, good guy but who certainly doesn't have the background and experience that other candidates do?" Mr. Sprouse asked. "I think they're at a disadvantage. I don't think there's any question about it."
That said, Mr. Sprouse said he hoped Mr. Garrison would get the job.
Mr. Goodwin took a wry view.
"He would have had to have a great crystal ball, I guess, to see that Dave Hardesty would resign when some of his people were still on the board," Mr. Goodwin said.
Mr. Garrison did not respond to interview requests.
A nest of family ties
Mr. Garrison's time in the governor's office overlapped with that of Mr. Goodwin's sister-in-law, Kay H. Goodwin, who was the state's secretary of education and the arts under Mr. Wise and continues in that role today under Gov. Joe Manchin III.
The secretary is married to Stephen Goodwin's brother, U.S. District Judge Joseph R. Goodwin, who was chairman of the state Democratic Party in 1982. Another brother, Thomas, was executive assistant to former Gov. John D. Rockefeller IV (now a U.S. senator) in the 1970s.
Also serving Mr. Wise as press secretary while Mr. Garrison was in Charleston was Amy Shuler Goodwin, who is married to Kay and Joseph Goodwin's son.
Mr. Garrison stepped down this month as chairman of the Higher Education Policy Commission, which reviews the WVU president's proposed contract, salary and terms. The commission can reject a nominee selected by the board, but such a step would be highly unusual.
Many describe Mr. Garrison as a nontraditional candidate cut from the same cloth as Mr. Hardesty, himself a WVU alumnus, Charleston lawyer, Rhodes scholar and former state tax commissioner.
Mr. Hardesty, 60, who will step away in September from a salary of $275,000 after 12 years as WVU president, oversaw a period of growth in the school's enrollment, endowment and research.
Mr. Goodwin recalled that in contrast to his eventual success, Mr. Hardesty's inauguration was marred by campus protests, criticism over his lack of a high-powered academic record and a lawsuit that said the search committee was improperly constituted. Mr. Goodwin acknowledged that the current search had stirred some negative opinion, but nothing as severe as the last one.
"Do I think that everybody still has got a shot at this job? Absolutely. Any of the three," Mr. Goodwin said. "It's a small place and people are gonna say what they want, and I challenge anyone to point out to me anything that was inappropriate about the process."
The search began in September with more than 100 names. That was whittled down to more than 60, and then cut to eight semi-finalists -- four or five college or university presidents, three or four provosts, and Mr. Garrison. All eight were interviewed in person before the list was sliced to three.
"There was no one who had 100 percent support at those meetings," Mr. Goodwin said.
Dennis Barden, senior vice president and director of the higher education practice at Witt/Kieffer, in Chicago, is not involved in the WVU search but has participated in about 150 searches for top college administrators.
While political figures have been involved in college leadership, Mr. Barden said, it would be "an anomaly" for the fix to be in for any candidate.
"That happens in very, very few cases. Do I think it happens? Yes. Do I think it's standard operating procedures? Absolutely not. The vast majority of presidential searches, including the public sector -- especially the public sector because the public scrutiny is so intense -- are very much on the up and up," Mr. Barden said.
More presidents from outside
Mr. Barden said the popularity of nontraditional presidents, like Mr. Hardesty, has grown over the years because "the job of the presidency is changing to be more external, to be more about the marshalling and allocation of resources than about the core academic product of this institution. That continues to be the product of the faculty and the provost."
However, most college presidents still come from a college background. "The reason it's not becoming predominant is because at the end of the day, you're still running an academic enterprise," Mr. Barden said.
Robert Kreiser, senior program officer with the American Association of University Presidents, prefers college presidents to come from academic backgrounds.
"We've had concerns about the growing number of individuals without an academic background who are being chosen to lead colleges and universities," Mr. Kreiser said.
"The concern is they're not familiar with, not necessarily committed to, what colleges and universities stand for. Being the president of a college or university is too important a position for on-the-job training."
Claire Van Ummerson, vice president and head of the center for effective leadership of the American Council on Education, said most college and university presidents come from academia, although that varies by type of institution.
While the portion of nontraditional presidents had been growing, it has leveled off in recent years in American Council on Education surveys.
Overall, about 13 percent of presidents last year worked outside academia immediately before becoming a college president although most -- 63 percent -- worked outside higher education at some point in their careers.
Dr. Van Ummerson, who has been president of Cleveland State University and the New Hampshire system, has known candidates from the outside who have succeeded and those who haven't "because they've had troubles adapting to the campus culture."
The three candidates will have their final interviews during the next two weeks. The board of governors is expected to select WVU's 22nd president on April 13.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.