Kimberley Gsell was staying in a Middlesex Township motel with a woman to whom she’d recently become engaged.
But after Sept. 29, 2019, her family and friends stopped hearing from her, including her two children. Police suspected foul play in the disappearance of the 38-year-old woman, but her body was never found, and no charges were filed.
That changed on Friday, when David Snyder, 39, of Hanover, told investigators he hid Gsell’s body along Yellow Breeches Creek and led them to her skeletal remains, according to police.
Snyder was charged on Sunday with first-degree murder and strangulation. Magisterial District Judge Jon Birbeck ordered him held without bail at Cumberland County Prison because of the severity of the charges.
An affidavit of probable cause filed by Middlesex Township police gave this account:
Before she went missing, Gsell had become engaged to a woman while the woman was still married to Snyder. The women had checked into a Rodeway Inn on the 1200 block of the Harrisburg Pike on Friday, Sept. 27, 2019, and planned to check out two days later.
On Sept. 29, Snyder went to the motel and took his wife to a hospital because of a nose injury she said Gsell caused. When the woman returned, Gsell wasn’t in the room, she told police.
The woman gave numerous explanations to Gsell’s family and friends, while Snyder said he hadn’t seen Gsell on Sept. 29, the day of her disappearance.
During the yearslong investigation, police said they uncovered multiple inconsistent statements from Snyder and his wife.
When police presented the inconsistencies to Snyder during Friday and Saturday interviews, he told them he returned to the Rodeway Inn while his wife was being treated at the hospital for her nose injury, according to the affidavit.
The affidavit said Snyder convinced Gsell to get into his van under the guise that his wife wanted her to come see her at the hospital. Instead, the affidavit said he put her in a chokehold, using the back of her seat as leverage to kill her.
Snyder believed Gsell did not fight back because she was intoxicated, the affidavit said. Court documents said he then put her body in the backseat and wrapped her in a blanket before returning to the hospital to pick up his wife.
According to the affidavit, Snyder later concealed her body in a secluded area along the Yellow Breeches Creek in New Cumberland.
Snyder took investigators to the creek on Saturday, where they said they found an item resembling a bone. A Pennsylvania State Police K9 confirmed the presence of human remains, and anthropologists found remains that matched Snyder’s statements about the burial and clothing she was wearing, according to the affidavit.
Cumberland County District Attorney Seán McCormack said she was buried under rocks, still wrapped in the blanket. He said her body was in a remote area on a steep embankment.
Police said Snyder and his wife reported Gsell missing in 2019. Court documents did not say if Snyder’s wife knew about the killing. She has not been charged as of Monday.
Snyder and his wife are still married, McCormack said.
Middlesex Township police searched for Gsell for years and, in 2022, told PennLive they suspected foul play. Charges were filed against Snyder four days after the Cumberland County Crimestoppers advertised a $2,000 reward for information leading to her location and/or an arrest.
Snyder did not have a criminal history in Pennsylvania before the murder charges were filed. A preliminary hearing is scheduled for Oct. 7.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.