A Castle Shannon man pleaded guilty Monday to causing the fire last year that killed his teenage daughter.

Brian Shelleby, 47, pleaded guilty to third-degree murder and aggravated arson. He will be formally sentenced in the death of his 19-year-old daughter, Lakyn Shelleby, on Sept. 10.

Authorities initially responded to the home on Corbett Drive about 10 a.m. Sept. 14 for reports of an explosion and fire. Shelleby’s wife, Carly Shelleby, was able to escape the blaze, although she was badly burned. A detective testified at the preliminary hearing last year that when he watched security footage that captured the blaze, Carly Shelleby ran out of the house and “appeared to be on fire.”

Lakyn, who was upstairs when the fire began, made it down the stairs but was unable to get out. She was found unresponsive by firefighters about 20 feet from the front door. She was pronounced dead at the scene. The medical examiner later ruled her death a homicide caused by severe burns and smoke inhalation.

Advertise with us

According to the criminal complaint filed against Shelleby days after the fatal fire, Carly Shelleby said she and her husband had argued that morning: He wanted to stay at the family’s home but his wife told him he couldn’t, as they were separated.

She said Shelleby went to the basement and “she heard what sounded like liquid being poured downstairs in the garage,” according to the complaint. She said she saw her husband pouring the gasoline as he came up the stairs, and he continued pouring the gas throughout the first floor.

A fire marshal testified at the October preliminary hearing that he couldn’t say for certain whether Shelleby lit the trail of gasoline or if the vapors were ignited by the home’s gas oven — but that it was likely the latter.

Shelleby’s defense attorney at the time had tried to argue that that meant the fire wasn’t an arson.

Shelleby, though, told investigators in the aftermath of the fire that his original intent had been to burn the house down. He said that when he got outside after pouring the gas, he “realized what he was doing,” and started back inside just as the home exploded into flames.