Isaac Smith said he wanted to clear his name.
He’d heard it connected to rumors about the murder of his sometimes-paramour, Karli Short, and he wanted to get it sorted out sooner than later, he said. He called 911 the same day her body was found behind the McKeesport house she was staying at and set up an interview with police.
In the recording of his interview with police that was played in court on Wednesday, Smith was calm. He agreed to waive his right to an attorney and talk with Allegheny County homicide detectives, and he consented when they asked to download the contents of his iPhone.
Short, 26, was shot to death Sept. 13, 2021, as she walked out the backdoor of her house to meet someone. She was around five months pregnant at the time, and she believed Smith was the father, authorities said.
Smith told detectives Mark Restori and Erik Schlarp that he had met up with Short just a handful of times over the past two years, and their relationship was surface-level at best — he referred to it as a “booty call” kind of situation. He said he didn’t know anything about her or her family, and he hadn’t talked to her for two days.
He was at his long-term girlfriend’s house the night prior when Short was killed, he said. He hadn’t quite figured out how to tell the girlfriend that he might have a child on the way with Short, and that he wanted to wait to make sure the child was actually his, he said.
Read More
Smith told detectives that if the child was his, he would step in and be a father, although he noted that Short had told him that it might not be his.
“He was respectful and cooperative,” Restori told the jury Wednesday after the interview was played, and he “whole-heartedly” believed Smith when he said he had nothing to do with the murder.
“We totally believed he was telling the truth,” he said, noting that he never expected to have occasion to talk to him again.
Smith was charged with homicide in connection with the death of Short and the unborn child two months later.
Wednesday marked the second day of testimony in the case, which was originally set to be a death penalty trial. The District Attorney’s Office dropped their bid for capital punishment last year, citing only the “due consideration of all of the relevant facts and circumstances.”
Defense attorney Tom N. Farrell told jurors in his opening statements Tuesday that his client had no reason to kill Short: He told her he would be a father to it, but otherwise he wouldn’t be involved.
DNA tests only recently came back showing that Smith was not the father.
Farrell indicated he would try to prove to jurors that investigators focused only on Smith and did not explore other suspects. His cross examination of Restori pointed to that: He noted that investigators only checked for Smith’s license plate on nearby license plate readers, and they did not preserve video footage of vehicles driving through Short’s neighborhood that night.
Smith spent three hours at Allegheny County Police headquarters that evening, authorities said. Restori testified that Smith knew he was free to leave at any time, and police offered him snacks and drinks.
In fact, the detective said, they told him he could go to one of the nearby fast food joints and then come back, if he wanted.
He declined, but he did use a landline to call his mother, they said.
He asked if she’d heard about the shooting in McKeesport, then told her that he was apparently “one of the most recent people to talk to the girl who was shot.”
He said he hadn’t seen Short “in a month or so.”
Though only his half of the conversation is audible, Smith seemed to be trying to quell his mother’s fears: “Please, like, you have to work with me because this was really hard for me to even call you to give you this information, so I don’t want you going into that mode.”
Testimony will continue Thursday morning.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.