Officials at the Diocese of Greensburg said a former priest and police chaplain now accused of sexually assaulting two men in the 2010s was removed from ministry in 2018 after “concerns were presented” about Robert Byrnes’ conduct at a Pennsylvania State Police Camp Cadet program.
Cliff Gorski, a spokesman for the diocese, said while the concerns “were non-criminal in nature and did not involve any allegations of criminal conduct, they were consistent with inappropriate boundary concerns.”
Those concerns were presented to the Diocesan Clergy Review Board, which reviews allegations of misconduct. The board on Aug. 3, 2018, recommended Brynes be removed from active ministry and put on inactive status. The decision, Gorski said, was “in keeping with the Diocese’s Higher Standards zero-tolerance policy.”
Byrnes, 84, was arrested Friday on charges of aggravated indecent assault, official oppression and obstruction. He is accused of sexually assaulting a male kitchen employee at Christ our Shepherd in 2014. During that investigation, which began in March, investigators identified a second alleged victim who worked at Christ our Shepherd prior to the first man.
The Greensburg diocese makes public a list of clergy “with credible and substantiated claims against them.” Byrnes does not appear on that list, as Mr. Gorski said it is “only for those accused of child sexual abuse.”
Pennsylvania State Police Trooper Steve Limani on Monday addressed Brynes’ time as a state police chaplain, which spanned from the early 2000s until 2018. He said state police ended its relationship with Byrnes over “procedural stuff.”
“He, unfortunately, breached some procedural stuff that we require,” Limani said, noting that Brynes didn’t break any laws, “but he just didn’t follow along the procedures enough.”
He continued: “He was aloof with some procedures, therefore there was a separation.”
Limani declined to say what those procedures entailed outside of “it’s our rules within our own department” and that “right now, it’s not really pertinent … to our investigation.”
He said it wasn’t uncommon for Byrnes to attend police functions, including Camp Cadet, a police academy-style leadership camp, but there were restrictions.
“He’s not a trooper, so you can’t just freely move in and about a camp,” Limani said. “You’re required … to check in with and be escorted by law enforcement.
“There was never an accusation of Father Byrnes being [inappropriate] or inappropriately communicating with any of the attendees at camp.”
It wasn’t clear whether the “concerns” noted by Gorski and the “procedural stuff” cited by Limani were the same thing. Neither man immediately responded to a follow-up email seeking clarity.
Police: Photos suggest further victims
Limani said the photos found in Byrnes’ room were of “several” individuals that “appear to be young males. The trooper said investigators could not pinpoint whether the individuals were minors. He declined to say how old the photos appear to be or how many different individuals are in the photos.
Asked whether the photos are sexual in nature, Limani said there are “definitely some that would be considered that way.”
“It’s a matter of — were these photographs taken with the person’s knowledge and their willingness to do so and, if not, then obviously we have another victim,” he said. “And if we have another victim, then when did this take place? What were the circumstances around it? And without those individuals coming forward right now, we have two [victims], and that’s all we know of right now.”
Police wrote in the criminal complaint against Byrnes that both men recently confronted him in a recorded telephone call.
Authorities said Byrnes “begged” the men not to speak about the 2014 incidents with police or a therapist “for the sake of the reputation of the church, the priesthood, for other priests [and] for my family.”
Authorities noted that in the same phone call, Byrnes referenced his relationship with law enforcement and alluded to having used his connections to law enforcement to get at least one of the men out of a criminal matter.
Limani said Byrnes never tried to intervene on anyone’s behalf.
“I believe he was trying to use his association with Pennsylvania State Police or law enforcement to make … his victims think he could help them or that maybe they shouldn’t report things because he had a relationship with law enforcement,” he said.
The man whose allegations initiated the criminal investigation told police that he was working in the kitchen, bent over an ice machine, when Byrnes “put his hand down the back of his pants [and] into his underwear.” The man said Byrnes’ actions were “entirely unsolicited and unwelcome.”
The second individual worked in the Christ Our Shepherd kitchen prior to the first man. He told investigators and Byrnes struck up a friendship with him and started inviting him to his room to shower and clean up after work. According to the criminal complaint, Byrnes would come in and watch the man shower.
The man told police that Byrnes sometimes gave him alcohol and there were times he allegedly woke up “naked in Brynes’ bed the following morning.”
Other times, according to the complaint, Byrnes gave the man pornography and would watch him perform sex acts on himself, telling him it was “a way to be forgiven for sins and a way of confession through Byrnes’ official capacity as a priest and counselor.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.