A judge dismissed an Ohio man’s appeal of 160 littering violations after he was a no-show at his hearing Wednesday, leaving in place the more than $50,000 in fines ordered by the lower court judge.
Neither Jeremy Brokaw nor his attorney, Joshua Smith, appeared in front of Common Pleas Judge Thomas Flaherty to contest the Aug. 26 convictions related to dozens of antisemitic flyers Brokaw left throughout Squirrel Hill last year.
The summary appeal hearing was rescheduled twice before. Assistant District Attorney Michael Siegert told the judge he had called Smith’s office “multiple times, and he has declined to return any calls.”
He said all of the Pittsburgh police officers involved in the case were in court and prepared to testify. He gave the judge a copy of one of the inflammatory flyers but noted that because the charges are all related to littering, “the offensive material is really irrelevant.”
Flaherty dismissed the appeal based on the failure of either man to show up in court.
“Hopefully, we will not see Mr. Brokaw again,” the judge said.
Read More
Neither Smith nor Brokaw could be reached for comment Wednesday afternoon.
The attorney had previously defended his client’s actions after his conviction at a summary trial last year, calling them “at worst, a misguided attempt at political advocacy.” He said the convictions seemed to run afoul of the First Amendment.
The dismissal of the appeal means the convictions and fines remain in place. Each citation — half of which were for littering and half for permitting someone else in the vehicle to litter — carries a $300 fine.
The flyers — which police and witnesses who saw them described as racist and antisemitic — appeared throughout Squirrel Hill just under a year ago. The papers were tucked into Ziploc-type bags filled with corn kernels and thrown from Brokaw’s light-colored Durango throughout Squirrel Hill and in parts of Shadyside on May 19.
Authorities linked the vehicle to Brokaw after police in Peters Township — where the same vehicle was involved in similar incidents days prior — provided them the license plate number.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.