The family of a woman who died after she fell into a sinkhole above an abandoned mineshaft in Unity in 2024 filed a wrongful death lawsuit Thursday against the property owner and U.S. Steel, alleging neither took adequate measures to address the risk posed by the abandoned mine.
Elizabeth Pollard was reported missing around 1 a.m. Dec. 3, about six hours after she was last seen looking for her lost cat, Pepper.
Authorities found her car near Monday’s Union Restaurant on Marguerite Road a few hours later. Her 5-year-old granddaughter was scared but safe inside the vehicle, which was parked about 20 feet away from a sinkhole that authorities ultimately discovered she’d fallen into.
Crews worked around the clock for four days, and the 64-year-old was eventually found dead about 30 feet down. She died from blunt force trauma, authorities said.
The lawsuit, filed by Ms. Pollard’s husband, Kenneth Pollard, names Paul Iannuzzo, the owner of Monday’s Union Restaurant, and U.S. Steel, the owners of the former mine. It also cites unnamed entities that might have also shared responsibility for maintaining the area.
Mr. Iannuzzo could not be immediately reached. A spokesperson for U.S. Steel said it is reviewing the lawsuit.
Read More
“Elizabeth Pollard should still be alive,” Morgan & Morgan founder John Morgan and attorney Mark Malone said in a joint statement. “The defendants’ alleged failure to provide and maintain a safe environment caused her preventable and untimely death.”
Ms. Pollard’s death, they said, “robbed a family of a beloved wife, mother, and grandmother.”
The lawsuit, filed in the Westmoreland County Common Pleas Court, alleges U.S. Steel and Mr. Iannuzzo were responsible for the maintenance, care and safety of the property where the sinkhole opened.
The area, according to the lawsuit, “was a highly susceptible area of collapse due to years of prior mining.”
The filing also alleges the defendants failed to, among other things, properly map the area and monitor subsidence zones as well as restrict the dangerous area or fix the unsafe conditions.
The massive search saw rescue crews using heavy machinery and their hands to dig into the ground adjacent to the sinkhole, eventually creating a trench that connected to the mine shaft area. The state Bureau of Abandoned Mine Reclamation filled in the sinkhole and the hole made during recovery efforts in the days and weeks after Ms. Pollard was recovered.
The sinkhole led to the Marguerite Mine, which was developed, mined and then abandoned by the H.C. Frick Coke Co. by the middle of the last century. The mine once fed coal to coke ovens and then steel mills in Pittsburgh and across the Eastern U.S.
The mine is one of many such mines along a strip spanning from Derry Township to Mount Pleasant. The Marguerite Mine specifically encompassed more than 1,000 acres underground.
Authorities said that Unity is one of hundreds of “patch towns” across the region — communities built atop abandoned mines.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.