The District Attorney’s Office will no longer seek the death penalty against the man charged with killing McKeesport police Officer Sean Sluganski and wounding Officer Chuck Thomas in February 2023.
District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. wrote in a notice to the judge that the decision came after weighing its evidence against Johnathan Morris and the mitigation evidence gathered by his defense attorney — including Mr. Morris’ psychiatric records.
Mr. Morris, 34, is awaiting trial for first-degree murder of a law enforcement officer and other charges in connection with the deadly Feb. 6, 2023, shooting. Officers Sluganski and Thomas responded to Mr. Morris’ home after his mother — a former McKeesport officer herself — called 911. She told the dispatcher that her son, a military veteran, had become aggressive and was suffering from a post-traumatic stress episode.
The officers followed Mr. Morris throughout the neighborhood — Officer Sluganski on foot and Officer Thomas in his patrol vehicle. He’s accused of opening fire on both men, killing the former and hitting the latter in the face and neck.
The notice rescinding the possibility of the death penalty noted that prosecutors and the defense team have “conducted extensive due diligence” in gathering evidence for their respective cases. The DA’s office wrote that Mr. Morris’ defense team turned over its mitigation evidence — including psychiatric records — on Friday.
Prosecutors wrote that they analyzed the records as well as expert reports and that, “following due consideration of all the relevant facts and circumstances, the commonwealth has decided not to seek a penalty of death.”
Read More
A status hearing in the case is set for April 13, and jury selection is scheduled to begin April 27.
It is the sixth time in less than two years that prosecutors have nixed the death penalty in cases in which they had initially sought the sentence.
In early October 2024, the DA withdrew its request to seek the death penalty in the case against Sean Black. Black is accused of gunning down his ex-girlfriend and mother of his three children inside the Blawnox warehouse where they both worked in March 2024.
In that case, prosecutors noted that the victim’s family had “expressed its opposition to the Commonwealth seeking the death” out of concern for the children. Black pleaded guilty to third-degree murder just under a year later. He was sentenced to 30 to 60 years in prison.
Later that month, the DA’s office decided prosecutors would no longer pursue the death penalty against Ronald Steave, who was set to go to trial a week later in a 2021 triple homicide. The district attorney cited an “untimely” defense motion and the judge’s refusal to postpone the trial to give prosecutors time to respond. Steave was ultimately convicted in the triple slaying and sentenced to life in prison.
In early 2025, one month before trial, the DA’s office withdrew the potential for the death penalty against Calvin Crew, who kidnapped and killed his Uber driver in 2022. While the DA’s filing in that case cited only “intervening events,” it came the same day that defense attorneys signaled they would introduce evidence that Crew was intellectually disabled and therefore not eligible for the death penalty,
A jury convicted Crew of first-degree murder, and he was sentenced to life in prison.
In June, the office rescinded the death penalty notice against Isaac Smith, who is accused of killing his pregnant girlfriend outside her McKeesport home in 2021. Police allege Mr. Smith lured Karli Short outside with a phone call and shot her. She was five months pregnant at the time.
Prosecutors in that case gave little in the way of reasoning, writing in the filing: “Following due consideration of all of the relevant facts and circumstances, the Commonwealth has decided not to seek a penalty of death[.]”
Mr. Smith is set to go to trial next month.
In August, the office ended its 10-year pursuit of the death penalty against Cesar Mazza, who had been awaiting trial since 2015 for the murder of his ex-girlfriend, 19-year-old Tionna Banks, and her 72-year-old grandmother, Valorie Crumpton.
The pair were found dead inside Ms. Crumpton’s East Hills home in May 2015, two days after Ms. Banks had been reported missing. She had a protection from abuse order against Mazza, who had previously been accused of assaulting her. In nixing the possibility of a death sentence in that case, the DA’s office indicated “the victims’ family made known to the attorneys for the commonwealth that they no longer wish to proceed with the death penalty.”
In September, days before Mazza’s case was set to go to trial, the DA’s office struck a plea deal: 30 to 60 years in prison. The victims’ family members were outraged.
Only one death penalty case remains pending in Allegheny County: Nicole Virzi, who is accused of killing her friends’ infant and injuring his twin brother in Shadyside in 2024. Police at the time said Ms. Virzi, of San Diego, “was unable to provide any plausible explanation” for the injuries suffered by 6-week-old Leon Katz. Her trial is scheduled for later this year.
Pennsylvania has executed only three people since the death penalty was reinstated in 1978 and none since 1999. Former Gov. Tom Wolf in 2015 declared a moratorium on executions, and Gov. Josh Shapiro has pledged not to sign any death warrants during his tenure. Capital crimes continue to be prosecuted and death sentences issued.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.