Investigators used license plate readers, cellphone records and surveillance footage to link three men to a fatal 2024 shooting near a Penn Hills apartment complex, according to charges filed earlier this week.

Kelshon Lovelace, 24, Trevor Twyman, 23, and Lemoyne Williams, 18, are all charged with homicide in connection with the shooting death of 21-year-old Vanderlee Stevenson.

The shooting happened just before midnight on Dec. 5, 2024.

According to the criminal complaints against the men, a witness drove with Mr. Stevenson to a spot on Universal Road “to meet a few people.” The witness didn’t know who they were meeting, but a man had FaceTimed Mr. Stevenson shortly before the pair arrived at the spot, saying he would flash his lights to signal Mr. Stevenson where to go.

Advertise with us

The witness said Mr. Stevenson got out and into the other vehicle, a dark SUV, according to the complaint. The witness heard muffled gunshots and saw two people run from the SUV. They got back in as the vehicle took off.

Less than two hours later, according to the complaint, a man ultimately identified as Twyman showed up at UPMC McKeesport with a gunshot wound to his left hand. He told police he had been outside his girlfriend’s apartment in Homestead when he was hit by a bullet.

Police tracked the vehicle that dropped him off at the hospital backward, linking it to another witness who said Twyman, an acquaintance, had been dropped off at the witness’s McKeesport home early Dec. 6, 2024. Using surveillance footage from the area, detectives identified the car that dropped off the injured defendant as a Chevy Malibu, the complaint says.

Days earlier, another witness, Lovelace’s “paramour,” told police that Lovelace had recently bought a Chevy Malibu, according to the complaint. The witness said Lovelace used her 2014 Kia Sorento the night of the shooting and, when Lovelace returned, he told the witness to report the Kia stolen. The Kia was later found covered in blood in Pittsburgh’s East Hills neighborhood.

Mr. Williams was linked to the crime through his phone number, which was the number that FaceTimed with — and had been texting with — Mr. Stevenson in the lead-up to the shooting. Records showed his cellphone moving in tandem with Lovelace’s cellphone leading up to and after the shooting.

Police said Lovelace and Twyman were already incarcerated on unrelated charges, and Williams was taken into custody Thursday morning. Although Williams was a juvenile at the time of the shooting, he is charged as an adult.