A Sewickley man, initially charged with homicide alongside two co-conspirators in 2022, pleaded guilty Tuesday to hindering apprehension.

Common Pleas Judge Bruce Beemer sentenced Joseph Koller, now 24, to up to 23 months incarceration, assuring that his sentence will be served in the Allegheny County Jail as opposed to the state prison system.

Police said Koller was behind the wheel of his silver BMW late in the afternoon on May 9, 2022, when he drove Nazair Macon and Malik Terry to Pittsburgh’s Allentown neighborhood. Those men opened fire minutes later, killing 17-year-old Isaiah Anderson as he stood in front of Adan Market on East Warrington Avenue. Terry and Macon pleaded guilty last year to third-degree murder and were each sentenced to 15 to 30 years in prison.

Surveillance cameras captured the BMW circling the area around the 700 block of East Warrington several times in the minutes before the shooting. It pulled out of view on Millbridge Street before two men — at least one of whom could be seen riding in the passenger seat in the previous footage — walking toward Adan Market from the alley behind East Warrington.

Advertise with us

Macon and Terry fired more than two dozen shots, killing Isaiah and wounding two others who were in front of the market. The two fled the scene, and the BMW was captured on camera leaving Allentown moments after the shooting. Police said they believed Koller coordinated with the other two as to where he would pick them up after the shooting.

Police identified Koller through his car. Investigators later turned up messages sent by Koller that indicated he knew he’d been party to a shooting and included a video of first responders attempting to save Isaiah.

Judge Beemer said ahead of handing down the sentence that he couldn’t see a scenario in which he sentenced Koller to anything less than incarceration.

“The nature of the offense, impact on the victims, and severity of the crime outweigh the substantial mitigating factors,” he said.

He sentenced Koller to 6 to 23 months in jail followed by two years of probation. He said he’d be amenable to Koller serving that time in alternative housing.