Two of three men charged with gunning down a teenager in Allentown in 2022 took plea deals Tuesday morning, a move decried by the victim’s family but called “the best outcome” by the District Attorney’s Office.
Isaiah Anderson’s mother said the men deserved more than the 15 to 30 years they received in exchange for third-degree murder pleas.
“He was shot 17 times,” Monica Reifman said, noting that if East Warrington Avenue had been more crowded that day, “this could have been a mass shooting event.”
She called the fact that the men could get out of prison in their early 30s “is a miscarriage of justice.”
The defendants — 20-year-old Nazair Macon and 21-year-old Malik Terry — told Judge Bruce Beemer they felt let down by their defense attorneys. They took the plea deals nonetheless.
“I took my plea, nothing I say in here matters,” Macon told the judge.
Isaiah was 17 and one month away from graduating when he was gunned down in a hail of bullets May 9, 2022. Authorities say Macon, Terry, and 23-year-old Joseph Koller fired some 30 shots that injured two others on the street that day.
It wasn’t clear Tuesday if Mr. Koller would also plead guilty or if he would go to trial.
Investigators used surveillance footage to identify a vehicle that had circled the area several times in the lead-up to the shooting. The vehicle tracked back to Mr. Koller, whose cellphone contained a video that showed the three defendants together about 30 minutes before the shooting.
Isaiah’s grandmother, Wanda Anderson, wrote in a statement read in court that her grandson was a happy straight-A student. She said the family collected nine school-related awards on his behalf after his death.
Deputy District Attorney Ryan Kiray told the judge he knew Isaiah’s family was against the plea deal and wanted the case to proceed to trial, but he and the DA’s office believed the pleas offered the best possible outcome in the case.
“They feel as though the state doesn’t care about the victim,” he said. “I’m sorry they feel that way.”
Judge Beemer said he couldn’t change the terms of the plea deal; rather, he could only accept or reject it. He accepted the pleas, reiterating the Mr. Kiray’s assertion that the pleas were in everyone’s best interest.
“I can’t even be mad,” Terry said when given the opportunity to speak. “If it was the other way around, my mom would want them to get life.”
Macon told Isaiah’s family that he was sorry for their loss but “we’re losing our youth.”
“Three Black kids are losing their lives,” he said, calling himself and the other defendants “a product of our environment.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.