After Bailey Gizienski clocks out from her 9-to-5 job at a medical marijuana dispensary, she pulls a 5-to-9 shift at her kitchen table, looking for her long-lost relative.

She is one of “Cherrie’s Angels,” four women who sift through crime tips, answer emails and make dozens of phone calls in hopes they’ll crack one of the state’s oldest unsolved criminal cases — the disappearance of 8-year-old Cherrie Mahan 40 years ago from a school bus stop in Butler County.

The case is so old that Cherrie was the first child featured in “Have you seen me?” postcards sent out by the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children and ADVO direct mail company several months after her abduction.

Fueled by caffeine and cinnamon sugar pretzels, Gizienski and other distant relatives of Cherrie’s mother, Janice McKinney, run through scenarios of what might have happened to the doe-eyed girl who disappeared minutes after stepping off a school bus near her home on Cornplanter Road in Winfield Township on Feb. 22, 1985.

Advertise with us

In 40 years, police have never named a suspect, but McKinney and her family and friends, including the Psychic Vincent Sisters of Butler, have never stopped looking for answers.

A bumper crop of tips came in this year, spurred by the Cherrie’s Angels’ Facebook page, “Find Cherrie Mahan”, and a $100,000 reward from an out-of-state investigator, Steve Ridge. State police and the FBI recently searched an Armstrong County site, and cadaver dogs detected hits on a private property. More searches are in the works.

This is the most action McKinney has seen for decades on her daughter’s case. Her passion hasn’t waned, but she is tired. She doesn’t have the strength that she did when she was a young mother.

McKinney, 65, of Saxonburg, has recently corresponded with a person of interest in the case and is waiting, again, for answers.

“I truly believe he knows. Whether he blames his father or anyone else, he knows what happened to Cherrie, or at least he thinks he knows,” she said.

Advertise with us

Where it happened

The area around Cornplanter Road still lives up to its name, with acres of cornfields and grass and modest homes, some meticulous, even the doublewide trailers.

There’s plenty of space in this rural township of only 3,360 people. The roads are quiet except for occasional traffic and the hum of yard and farm machinery.

The intersection of Cornplanter and Winfield roads in Winfield Township, Butler County, near where Cherrie Mahan went missing 40 years ago. (Mary Ann Thomas / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Families know one another. Cherrie’s babysitter lived nearby and took the 8-year-old to the school bus stop on days when McKinney started her early morning shift at a nursing home.

McKinney is still friends with the woman today. Long-lasting and tight friendships are hallmarks of this region, and it’s hard for residents to accept that a child predator might still live in their midst.

Cherrie’s birth was a gift to her grandparents, the late Shirley and Alvin Mahan, who lived in nearby Clinton Township, another close-knit, rural community.

Advertise with us

“It gave my parents new vigor for life,” McKinney said. “She was their whole world. Cherrie was a lifesaver for my mother after my father died in 1981.”

When she and Cherrie lived with her parents, Shirley Mahan would rise in the morning, get the mail and be gone all day with Cherrie in tow. As the township tax collector, she often took her granddaughter with her on local trips and errands.

“Cherrie knew everybody because of my mom,” McKinney said.

The child was so attached to her grandmother that she would go with her mother to the church where Shirley Mahan sang in the choir. If they were late and sat in a back pew, Cherrie would crawl on the floor to reach the front to be close to her grandmother.

Cherrie’s ‘amazing’ angels

McKinney’s four relatives, ages 22-30, launched the “Find Cherrie Mahan” Facebook page in January to encourage tips from the public.

Advertise with us

“They came alongside me and are amazing,” McKinney said. “A lot of stuff goes through them, and I try to stay out of it. I just get too emotional.

“If I had to, I would get into my car and do a few people in, that is for sure.”

Although she admits she wouldn’t really harm someone, McKinney said her frustration is almost unbearable because she has been searching so long.

She suspects that her daughter’s assailant is likely someone she has known all along.

“I truly believe there are people out there who know what happened, but I don’t think they are willing to talk at the moment,” McKinney said.

Advertise with us
The Psychic Vincent Sisters of Butler, Suzanne, left, and Jean, right, with Cherrie Mahan’s mother, Janice McKinney, in 2023. (Courtesy of Suzanne Vincent)

With Cherrie declared dead in 1998, at this point McKinney is looking for closure and to bring her daughter’s remains home.

“As a parent, I need to know for sure because, truthfully, this has sucked the life right out of me. I put on a good front for everybody. There are days when I don’t come out of my room. It’s just so unfair that someone took an amazing little girl from me.”

Gizienski, a distant relation who grew up near McKinney’s home, wasn’t alive when Cherrie went missing. In the last five years, she and McKinney have become close, vacationing and camping together.

In January, while having dinner at the Hardwood Cafe in Penn Township, McKinney broke down when the conversation turned to Cherrie. “I can’t keep on living like this,” she told Gizienski and others.

The incident was a cry for help for Gizienski and other family members. “So the young’uns went home that night and decided to help,” she said.

Advertise with us

They researched the case and founded the Facebook group just weeks after their dinner with McKinney to publicize the 40-year anniversary of the unsolved case and open an anonymous tip line via the page’s private messenger function.

“The past year has been one of the most challenging years of my life,” Gizienski said. “It keeps me going, and we won’t stop until Janice gets her answer and Cherrie is brought home.”

On Feb. 22, the 40th anniversary of Cherrie’s disappearance, they staged a public event with fingerprinting and other identification resources for children at the Saxonburg VFW Post. Hundreds of people showed up and lines extended out the door, Gizienski said.

“For the first time, I saw hope in Janice. She couldn’t believe how many people cared that much. Not that she lost hope, but I could tell there wasn’t much left during that January dinner.”

The Cherrie’s Angels Facebook page drew hundreds of tips, which were forwarded to state police, Gizienski said. “From there, things skyrocketed. It’s been the craziest year of my life.”

Advertise with us

Many tips came from people who live within an hour’s drive of Saxonburg. Some came from the Pittsburgh area, she said.

State police declined to comment on the tips because they cannot release information on what they are calling an “active investigation.”

“The Pennsylvania State Police are dedicated to solving this and other missing persons cases, regardless of how much time has passed, so that families and affected communities can have the closure they deserve,” said Myles Snyder, communications director for the state police in Harrisburg.

Members of Cherrie’s Angels believe multiple people were involved in the child’s disappearance.

“Tips included corroborating stories of sexual assault and abuse in our community in the 1980s when Cherrie went missing,” Gizienski said.

Advertise with us

“I believe the police at the very beginning failed her. I believe they got tunnel vision and they tried to look at Janice and Leroy (her husband) for so long. They missed what was directly under their nose.”

Jancie married Leroy McKinney, Cherrie’s stepfather, in 1982. He died in 2018.

The women pursued national exposure and a deeper investigation of the case. On Sept. 30, Cherrie’s story was told on the Crime Junkie podcast, which reaches millions of listeners. SiriusXM ranked the show as the number one most listened to podcast in the country in 2023. The segment on Cherrie sparked more tips and insights into the case.

An age-progression rendering of what Cherrie Mahan might have looked like at age 38. (National Center for Missing & Exploited Children)

Was someone stalking Cherrie?

The investigation initially focused on people associated with McKinney. For years, she was suspicious of Cherrie’s biological father, a local man whom she would not name. McKinney alleged that the man, who was associated with a motorcycle gang, raped her when she was 15 years old.

Police also focused on a van with a ski mural parked near McKinney’s property as well as a small blue car.

Advertise with us

She has weathered criticism and suspicions that she or her late husband were involved in Cherrie’s disappearance because of their drug use.

McKinney said there were drugs like marijuana and cocaine around when she was a young teenager, but she didn’t use drugs until she met Leroy McKinney, a Vietnam War vet who became addicted to painkillers after breaking his neck.

“After Cherrie was kidnapped ... I did more drugs than you could shake a stick at,” she said.

There were rumors that McKinney was drinking at a bar the day Cherrie went missing.

“I was home,” she said. “Cherrie wanted me to make tuna fish sandwiches. She wanted to come straight home after school to go away to a friend’s birthday party.”

Advertise with us

Leroy McKinney’s drinking and drug use came up when police interviewed the couple right after Cherrie went missing. One officer brought up a previous incident when Leroy had driven into a building after drinking.

McKinney thinks that her husband was likely drunk, and that the officer was focusing on them as suspects because of the incident.

“I felt he was holding past things against us and now we’re here and our daughter was kidnapped.

“I could give a flying fart what anybody thinks of me because I know who I am, what I am and what I have done,” McKinney said.

“Am I ashamed? Maybe back in the day when I was 14 or 15. After I had Cherrie — no! She was a gift God gave me. She and I grew up together. We were good friends as well as mother and daughter. I have learned there are very cruel people in this.”

Advertise with us

In the early days after Cherrie’s disappearance, the possibility of a sexual predator didn’t come up, at least when police updated the family on the case, McKinney said. But looking back, she noticed unusual behavior from Cherrie.

The McKinneys moved to their Cornplanter Road home about six months before Cherrie was taken.

Cherrie was given the front bedroom, but her mother would often find her sleeping on the floor. The child explained that she was afraid because someone was looking at her through her bedroom window.

McKinney hung thermal curtains and eventually moved Cherrie to another bedroom. It wasn’t until years later that McKinney realized the potential significance of Cherrie’s statement.

Suspects and suspicions

Currently, among the hundreds of tips to Cherrie’s Facebook page are dozens about a Saxonburg-area family living near McKinney’s home before she moved to Winfield Township, Gizienski said.

Advertise with us

The Post-Gazette will not publish the name of the family because no family member has been charged or named as a suspect by police. One family member is a convicted pedophile, according to state court records.

McKinney now believes her daughter was stalked by someone they knew.

The Psychic Vincent Sisters, Jean and Suzanne Vincent of Butler County, first raised the possibility of a sexual predator in the case about 25 years ago.

The Vincents have garnered national attention as psychic mediums and paranormal investigators who volunteer their services to families and police in missing persons and murder cases.

In Cherrie’s case, the sisters say they are “psychic sleuthing” — using traditional investigative techniques taught by the late Cyril Wecht, former Allegheny County coroner, to shake out leads by talking to people and sending their tips to police.

Advertise with us

Through decades of helping Janice McKinney, the sisters have gotten to know her family, friends and neighbors. They have attended events remembering Cherrie and maintain an informal hotline for tips.

They often receive tips from people who don’t want to talk to police.

Jean Vincent remembers a tip from around 2000 from someone who claimed they were molested at age 4 by a member of a family who once lived near Janice and Cherrie in the Saxonburg area.

“That was the first turning point, validating there was a pedophile on that street,” she said.

The Vincents said they discovered more information during psychic readings with local residents, including one woman who lived near Cherrie and her mother who said there were two generations of her family infected with the pedophilia “disease.”

Advertise with us

The sisters claim that shortly after the conversation, other family members contacted them and threatened the Vincents. A caller told them to mind their own business or they could be shot.

The sisters reported the incident to police, and both say they got gun permits after the incident.

They have submitted their information and tips to the state police for more than 30 years, they said.

More recently, Cherrie’s Angels said they have received multiple tips about pedophiles in the Saxonburg area and other reports of sexual crimes.

“What we’ve learned since setting up the Facebook pages is that people know what happened and who did it,” Gizienski said.

The Vincent sisters said many people don’t feel comfortable talking to police or discussing sexual abuse.

“We knew there were quite a few people who were molested,” Suzanne Vincent said. “We thought, ‘So wow, Janice didn’t do it.’ Everyone said the bikers did it.... There was a whole other backstory.”

Now in their 60s, the sisters said it’s more important than ever to bring the community together to find every bit of information to build a case.

“We've got to bring her home to the community,” they said. “She needs a final resting place.”

Where to provide tips

Pennsylvania State Police in Butler: (724) 284-8100

Cherrie’s Angels/Find Cherrie Mahan Facebook page: facebook.com/find.cherrie.mahan

The Psychic Vincent Sisters: psychicvincentsisters.com