“Profound and enduring.”
That was how the judge described the pain he saw in Benjamin Brallier’s family Tuesday morning, even now, more than a year since his murder.
But it was also how the judge described Ant Quesen’s mental illness and need for intensive treatment, regardless of the sentence he handed down. Quesen, 26, pleaded guilty but mentally ill earlier this year in connection with Mr. Brallier’s 2024 slaying.
Mr. Brallier, a 44-year-old state police Liquor Control Enforcement agent, was jogging along the Montour Trail in Moon midafternoon Oct. 21, 2024, when he was attacked and stabbed to death. A blood trail and yellow bicycle found at the scene led police to Quesen.
Police found Quesen that night near the Montour Woods Conservation Area, which is less than a mile from where Mr. Brallier was attacked. Investigators said there was blood on the suspect’s pants and socks and cuts on her hands. As police approached, Quesen allegedly told officers, without being asked, that a man stabbed her on the trail and took her bag.
Mr. Brallier’s family asked Common Pleas Judge Edward J. Borkowski to impose the maximum sentence for third-degree murder: 20 to 40 years plus 3½ to 7 years for a robbery charge in a separate case.
Read More
“It’s not unexpected that you requested the maximum penalty,” Judge Borkowski said to the dozens of Mr. Brallier’s friends and family members that filled his fifth-floor courtroom as well as an overflow room. “Perhaps if I were sitting where you sit, I would feel the same.”
Quesen’s “uncontested, well-documented” mental health issues couldn’t be ignored, the judge said, while also noting Quesen “had every opportunity to stabilize … and chose not to.”
He sentenced the defendant to a combined 16 to 42 years in prison. The plea of guilty but mentally ill means Quesen will receive mental health treatment for the duration of the incarceration.
Some of Mr. Brallier’s family members shook their heads in dismay at hearing the sentence. They expressed continued ire toward the defendant, with Mr. Brallier’s mother calling Quesen a danger and “a burden to taxpayers.”
Signs of mental illness
“He is my superhero,” Peggy Brallier said of her son. “I mourn every day for him, and I will for the rest of my life.”
She said her son wore many hats, and that’s what family members described: A prankster, a Dave Matthews Band fan, the neighborhood handyman, a veteran liquor control agent, a champion for his daughters, and a loving husband with dreams of retiring to a beach somewhere with his wife, Sarah.
“We lost our center, our sense of security, and our plans for the future,” Sarah Brallier said, describing “a silence in our home that now feels unbearable.
“He should be here.”
Quesen apologized for taking away a man as good as the one his family described, saying the realization of how mentally ill she was — how paranoid she was — came only after medication and treatment.
“I was so paranoid that I thought someone who was a good dad, a good father — a good human being — was a murderer,” Quesen said, calling it “a mistake … I will regret for the rest of my life.”
Quesen’s mother, Sarah Quesen, described a happy childhood in which Quesen did well in school and excelled at art. She received a scholarship to a Maryland art school and, for her first few years there, her mother said, all was fine.
Signs of mental illness began showing themselves partway through Quesen’s junior year. Her mother chalked it up to stress at first — the COVID-19 pandemic loomed large at the time — but “it started to get worse.” Quesen became anxious and paranoid, believing the COVID-19 vaccine contained microchips.
She dropped out of school, her mother said, her relationship ended, and things got worse. She believed that people on the street were sniffing her, that men could vaporize and enter her apartment under the door, and that people — including her mother — were trying to poison her. She sniffed her food before she would eat it, her mother said.
When Quesen was arrested in June 2023 on charges of simple assault and robbery for an incident in Point State Park, her mother said she was relieved: “She was finally going to get some help.”
‘What the defendant deserves’
Quesen was released the same day she was arrested, but authorities recommended she receive mental health treatment.
And she did, for a while, her mother said.
“I was so angry when they let her out,” Sarah Quesen said, noting that Quesen didn’t believe she was mentally ill and she didn’t believe she needed medication.
She got a job for a while at an art center in Garfield, but “she was so paranoid she didn’t trust anyone.”
“She told me how helpless she felt,” her mother said.
At the Allegheny County Jail, she continued to suffer paranoia, her mother said, and visits were filled with crying and screaming. She wasn’t well, she said.
But when she was committed to Torrance State Hospital for treatment — where she was forced to take her medication — her mother saw an improvement. Sarah Quesen said she remembered the first time she saw her daughter eat a snack without sniffing it. Week by week, she said, their conversations became “like before she got sick.”
“She knows she wasn’t well and knows medication is important and necessary,” she said.
But Assistant District Attorney Chase Stelzer said that as soon as Quesen was no longer forced to take medication, she would become a danger again. That, he said, was why the judge should impose the max sentence.
“The moment [she] gets out of jail is the moment this community is at grave risk,” he said.
Mr. Brallier’s family members said the maximum sentence would bring with it justice and a level of closure.
Bayleigh Brallier listed out for the judge all the “firsts” her father had already missed — her eighth grade graduation, her first day of high school, her first homecoming dance — and those that he’ll miss in the future, too.
“He won’t be there for my 16th birthday,” she said. “I won’t have him to walk me down the aisle.”
She didn’t want pity, Bayleigh told the judge.
“I just want what the defendant deserves,” she said, “and that is to not be walking the same streets as long as possible.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.