For U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, it was hailed as a critical program that would give local law enforcement agents sweeping powers to stop, report, and lock up immigrants who were breaking the law.

Launched in 2002, the plan allowed ICE to deputize police and sheriff's offices in border states such as Texas and Florida and root out thousands of serious criminals who were in the country illegally.

But as the mission of ICE rapidly grew into a nationwide enforcement crackdown, the 287(g) program has reached into nearly every corner of Pennsylvania at a pace never before seen.

In just eight months, more than 40 agencies across the state — including sheriff's offices in Butler, Beaver, and Westmoreland counties — have struck agreements with ICE, giving the U.S. government a reach into areas that it never had.

Advertise with us

While supporters in local communities have celebrated the partnerships as a way to strengthen public safety, the surge of the program has also led to protests, criticism and a legal challenge that could change immigration enforcement in the state for years to come.

The debate over the program in Pennsylvania comes as the Trump administration carries out one of the most aggressive immigration campaigns in U.S. history, leading to at least 3,250 arrests in the commonwealth alone.

Charles Tanner speaks against Butler County's cooperation with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement during a Butler County Board of Commissioners meeting on Wednesday, July 9, 2025 at the Butler County Government Center building. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

In Butler County, residents took to the podium during a county commissioners meeting in July, pleading with commissioners to stay out of a deal that had already been signed by the sheriff.

“It just shows where we’re at,” said resident Pauline Peluso. “Now we jump on this bandwagon. Why? There’s no reason.”

But a top county officials commended the arrival of the program, saying she supported the decision by Sheriff Michael Slupe to join ICE in the effort.

Advertise with us

“I trust the sheriff to say he’s not going to do something that’s not constitutional or against the law,” said Leslie Osche, county commission chairwoman. “If there’s not a warrant and there’s not particularly paperwork that’s at play, he’s not going to get involved.”

The growth of the 287(g) is expected to intensify in the coming months in the wake of a court decision in Bucks County last week that allowed the sheriff to cut his own deal with the federal agency instead of getting county commission approval.

Though plaintiffs argued that Sheriff Frederick Harran didn’t have the power to sign the agreement with ICE, Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey Trauger dismissed the claim in a ruling that was watched by top county officials across the state.

In a social media post, Sheriff Harran called the decision “a victory for the law-abiding residents of Bucks County and a validation of a common-sense approach to public safety which fully leverages partnerships and resources to keep our communities safe.”

Two groups fighting the rights of the sheriffs to forge alliances with ICE plan to appeal the decision, saying it would open the door to abuses and rampant racial profiling.

Advertise with us

“This is not about public safety,” said Diana Robinson, co-executive director of one of the groups, Make the Road Pennsylvania, a non-profit in Allentown. “This is about turning our neighborhoods into surveillance zones. This is about weaponizing local law enforcement to carry out ICE’s harmful agenda.”

From its beginnings in 1996, the 287(g) has targeted serious offenders nationwide — and aimed to deport them.

In deal after deal, local law enforcement agencies acted as arms of federal immigration officials, rooting out undocumented criminals — including sex offenders and drug traffickers — in their communities.

As the program evolved, it was set up to provide training to local police in stopping, reporting and detaining aliens.

Though adopted by just a handful of agencies early on — the first one joining in 2002 —  287(g) would make its mark in enforcement during the first term of President Donald Trump, growing from just 35 local departments to at least 150.

Advertise with us

But the program also ran into problems over the past two decades, at times capturing headlines.

Two investigations by federal prosecutors — one into the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office in Arizona in 2011 and one at the Alamance County Sheriff’s Office in North Carolina the next year — found the agencies had engaged in practices of racial profiling and constitutional violations after joining the program.

In both counties, the program was suspended as a result of the probes.

Another in Connecticut was terminated during the COVID-19 pandemic after officers used stun guns, pepper spray and dogs on immigrants who were protesting conditions at a jail.

Though ICE said the program would target serious crimes among immigrants, an investigation by the Government Accountability Office more than a decade ago found that local officers were rounding up and arresting immigrants for small infractions, such as speeding and open container violations.

Advertise with us

In 2021, a Washington Post investigation found the partnerships could be costly to local governments.

In Frederick County, Md., a longtime 287(g) partner, officials paid $725,000 to settle two cases after deputies detained two undocumented women with no criminal backgrounds, the newspaper reported.

Despite its past problems, the program has seen another surge in support since Trump entered office for a second term. More than 1,000 agencies across the country are now partnered with ICE, a 650% increase in just nine months.

Over the past several months, ICE has heaped praise on the program as a tool in helping to stem the tide of illegal immigration.

The agency is removing “the worst of the worst including murderers, gang members, rapists, terrorists, and pedophiles from our country,” said ICE Deputy Director Madison Sheahan in a statement last month.

Advertise with us

Fueled by an explosion in federal funding, ICE is now pouring more public dollars into 287(g) than ever before.

While the program was not designed to pay local agencies for taking part – other than funding the training of officers – ICE said last month it will now reimburse the full salaries of officers.

That includes benefits and overtime and incentives for local agencies to join. “ICE is not only supercharging our hiring, we are also multiplying partnerships with state and local law enforcement,” Ms. Sheahan said.

As the push to expand the 287(g) program continues, some local officials said they have no plans to partner with ICE, including Allegheny County Sheriff Kevin Kraus.

“I’ve not been approached; I’ve not been asked; I have not considered or put any consideration into such an agreement,” Sheriff Kraus said.

Advertise with us

The sheriff said his deputies are notified when ICE agents enter court buildings and are tasked with maintaining decorum and security during courthouse immigration arrests.

But his office does not directly assist in those arrests, which continue to be an explosive issue throughout the state.

“I will not allow any political feelings or agendas to intersect with my duty and public safety,” he said.

Members of the Butler County Board of Commissioners meet on Wednesday, July 9, 2025 at the Butler County Government Center building. The meeting was attended by members of the public, many of whom spoke against the county's cooperation with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

In Butler County, where Sheriff Slupe signed an agreement with ICE in June, other officials remain torn on the county’s participation. County Commissioner Kevin Boozel — the lone Democrat on the three-person board — said his biggest concern is possible lawsuits.

“If something happens, we’re going to get hammered,” Mr. Boozel said.

Advertise with us

In August, the same day an ICE agreement was struck with Beaver County Sheriff Tony Guy, county commissioners voiced a similar alarm during a public meeting.

Commission Chairman Daniel Camp questioned whether the county’s insurance would cover mishaps “if the sheriff’s office goes out and gets into an accident or causes harm to somebody.”

It remains to be seen whether the partnerships will result in more immigrant arrests, which continue at an unprecedented pace in Pennsylvania.

Since Trump took office through the end of July, there were more than 1,050 arrests from the 287(g) program in Florida, the most in the nation; at least 435 in Georgia, and about 350 in South Carolina.

Hundreds more have occurred in Arkansas, North Carolina and Oklahoma, according to ICE data compiled by the Deportation Data Project.

Advertise with us

In Pennsylvania, where the program is just starting to take root, only two arrests had been made through the end of July, both in the eastern part of the state. The number of detentions since that date is not currently available.

Ms. Osche, the Butler County Commissioners chairwoman, said she believes joining forces with ICE will bolster local law enforcement.

“I’m going to support the immigration laws and I’m going to support, most importantly and above all else, public safety,” she said.

As the partnership unfolds, officials will monitor actions by sheriff’s deputies, she said.

“There have been no cases yet,” she said. “But everything we watch, everything we do, we review everything with a fine-tooth comb.”

Advertise with us

Immigration advocates, however, warn that the 287(g) program will thrust local police into an unfamiliar role that will bring risks.

“They are not equipped to navigate the complexities of immigration law,” said leaders of the groups that pressed the civil case in Bucks County — the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania and the nonprofit Make The Road Pennsylvania.

Both groups said they would appeal the common pleas judge’s ruling, explaining that they believe 287(g) will leave families fearful of being “torn apart.”

“We will not be silent. We will not be complicit,” the groups said in a statement. “We will continue to fight in the courts, in the streets, in our communities.”