Without sound, it was almost hard to tell what happened in the video taken at Frankstown and North Homewood avenues on March 30, 2022.
The somewhat pixelated footage captured by a city camera showed 15-year-old Dayvon Vickers ride across the intersection on his minibike at 6:06 p.m. It was unseasonably warm — the sun hadn’t set yet, and it was still in the high 60s.
The footage, played for jurors Wednesday afternoon, showed the teenager slow to let cars go past. As he paused, one of two men across the street appeared to raise his arm. Dayvon fell to the sidewalk, his minibike toppling with him. The man across the street, wearing black pants with what the prosecutor described again and again as a distinctive white pattern, took off.
For several long minutes, cars continued to pass by the fallen teenager. During that time, Shaun Scott — the man police and prosecutors say shot Dayvon in the street — fled the area.
Testimony in Scott’s murder trial began Wednesday morning.
Assistant District Attorney Matthew Rabinowitz told jurors that two separate police officers identified Scott as one of the men in the video, and they found the same distinct pants in a laundry pile when they searched his home months later.
Read More
But defense attorney Frank Walker II said those identifications are unreliable, calling the entire investigation “incomplete.” He called the prosecutor’s case one that will “make you guess what happened” rather than proving what happened beyond a reasonable doubt.
Police charged Scott with Dayvon’s murder on July 6, 2022 — four days after he was charged with killing another teenager weeks earlier. Eighteen-year-old Maleek Thomas was gunned down in the Hill District in the middle of the afternoon on June 24, 2022.
Scott is set to go to trial in connection with Thomas’ slaying next month.
Mr. Rabinowtiz called only one non-law enforcement witness Wednesday: Jaquae Horton, who testified that he knew Scott and was in a car with him in Wilkinsburg on June 12, 2022. Scott had picked him up earlier, he said, along with two others. They went to KFC in Wilkinsburg and then parked in an alleyway where they were “eating and smoking.”
Horton, who appeared reluctant to testify, said they were parked in the alley when he told Scott he’d noticed Wilkinsburg police officers watching them. Scott, he said, “threw me the firearm and ran out the car.”
“I got tossed the gun and he climbed out the window,” Horton said, noting that Scott had parked close to a garage and couldn’t open his door all the way, which is why he had to climb out of the window.
Everyone else in the car took off too, Horton testified. He ran last, he said, and he still had the gun he said Scott threw at him. He was the only one of the four to get caught.
The gun was ultimately linked to Dayvon’s murder, according to the testimony.
On cross examination, Mr. Walker challenged Horton’s allegations: He surely told the officer who arrested him that it wasn’t his gun, right? No? What about the judge at his preliminary hearing weeks later, or the judge at his subsequent arraignment?
He asked Horton if he was telling the truth when he pleaded guilty to the gun possession charge in front of now-retired Judge Anthony Mariani in April 2023 — a hearing that would have required him to tell the judge that he was pleading guilty because he was guilty, in this case, of possessing a gun.
Horton said yes — he said he was in possession of the gun.
“I never swore it was mine,” he said. “It was in my possession.”
Testimony in the case will continued Thursday.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.