A teenager already headed to trial on homicide charges now faces a second one after a judge on Friday ordered him to stand trial in a separate, unrelated slaying.

Shaun Scott, 18, is accused of gunning down 15-year-old Dayvon Vickers as he rode his mini bike in Homewood on an unseasonably warm March 30.

Though authorities testified Friday they had an idea of Scott’s identity the day after Dayvon was killed, Scott was not arrested until July 2, just over a week after he allegedly killed 18-year-old Maleek Thomas, a recent high school graduate, in the city’s Hill District.

Though the hearing was in regard to shooting that killed Dayvon, Thomas’ family members attended nonetheless, wearing black hoodies with “Maleek” written in purple letters. His mother’s shirt had her son’s photo on the front of it.

Advertise with us

She hugged Dayvon’s grandmother in the hallway outside the courtroom.

District Judge Michele Santicola ultimately ordered Scott to stand trial on all charges after a roughly hour-long hearing in Pittsburgh Municipal Court.

Scott’s defense attorney, Kenneth Haber, took issue with the way in which his client was identified by police.

Investigators took still images from security cameras inside a convenience store where Scott allegedly was just before the shooting. Detective Janine Triolo said she sent three still photos to all officers in the bureau on March 31, the day after the shooting.

Zone 2 Officer Evan Mulzet testified that he immediately recognized Scott in the photos and responded to Detective Triolo with his name and date of birth.

Advertise with us

Mr. Haber said that was not an identification, but rather an opinion.

“It’s nothing more than bringing someone off the street and saying, ‘Give me your opinion,’” Mr. Haber argued. “He’s watching a movie and giving his opinion.”

Officer Mulzet testified that he’d seen Scott in person once when he’d arrested him as a juvenile in May 2021 and twice via a video call since then. He said he immediately recognized Scott in the still images Detective Triolo sent out, noting that his face was clearly visible.

Video footage showed a teen police identified as Scott walking out of the convenience store around the time Dayvon rode his mini motor bike onto the corner of Frankstown and North Homewood avenues The surveillance footage has no sound, but Dayvon can be seen falling to the ground.

His grandmother sat in the back of the courtroom, not looking at the screen.

Advertise with us

Mr. Haber also attempted to cast doubt on one of the key pieces of evidence — a pair of pants that Scott appeared to be wearing in the video footage that was later found inside his bedroom during a search initially connected to Thomas’ case.

Sgt. Joseph Lippert, one of the investigating officers on the case, testified he’d been called to assist in the search simply as extra manpower, and he was the one who discovered the black and white pants. He said officers halted the search, and he left to get a search warrant specific to those pants as they related to Dayvon’s case.

Mr. Haber pressed Sgt. Lippert on whether the pants had been inside a hamper in the bedroom, though the sergeant maintained that the pants were near the hamper but not inside of it.

Asked if the discovery was recorded on his body-worn camera, Sgt. Lippert said he wasn’t sure if he was wearing one and, if he was, if it was recording during the search. He said it is protocol to have one’s camera on and active during searches but “that’s not always the case” depending upon assignments or where an officer is called away from.

“If my [ballistic] vest was on me, my camera was on and recording,” he said.

Advertise with us

Cell phone records introduced as evidence showed a number connected to Scott was near the intersection at the time of the shooting. It later pinged off of a tower near his Princeton Avenue home in Wilkinsburg.

Mr. Haber questioned the validity of the cell phone science as presented by FBI Special Agent John Orlando, but Judge Santicola allowed the evidence to move forward.

Mr. Haber indicated he plans to dispute Officer Mulzet’s identification at trial and did not offer any closing argument.

A possible motive for Dayvon’s shooting was not introduced at the hearing. The Thomas shooting followed an outdoor confrontation.

Thomas’ mother, Camille Baskins, said police should have at least questioned Scott the same day Officer Mulzet identified him. She pointed out that detectives noted Scott had a juvenile record for aggravated assault.

Advertise with us

“They should have picked him up,” she said. “Maleek might be alive. They had enough evidence.

“Two young people, gone,” she said.