Sometimes, Deputy District Attorney Ilan Zur told jurors Tuesday, things are as simple as they seem.

“Every single piece of evidence in this case points to one person,” he said.

That person, he said during closing arguments — the individual who fired 16 rounds into a Monroeville police officer’s patrol car last year — is Jamal Brooks. The officer was hit twice and required extensive surgery to reconstruct his elbow.

Mr. Zur pointed to what he called overwhelming evidence: Brooks was arrested in the same area where the shooting happened; two guns, including the one used to shoot at Sgt. James MacDonald, were found near where Brooks was arrested; and Brooks had gunshot residue on his hands.

Advertise with us

Brooks, who has acted as his own attorney since the attempted-murder trial began last week in the Allegheny County Courthouse, told jurors he was a patsy in the Jan. 3, 2024, shooting near Stonecliffe Drive: He simply didn’t do it.

“He would have to be the unluckiest person in the world,” Mr. Zur said. “But we have more: We have video.”

A patchwork of dashboard camera and body-worn camera footage from officers who responded to the area that night in response to a nearby armed business robbery captures the shots fired at Sgt. MacDonald and Brooks’ subsequent arrest. It also shows the shooter’s distinct reflective orange vest.

Brooks, 33, conceded that it was him being arrested in the footage, and he was indeed wearing a reflective vest. But, he said, he wasn’t the same person wearing a reflective vest in the area who emptied an extended magazine into the sergeant’s car moments earlier.

Brooks accused the prosecution team, detectives and police officers, and the lab technicians who presented ballistic and other evidence of lying.

Advertise with us

“Everything done during this trial is manipulative,” he said.

Brooks has been charged with assault of a law enforcement officer, attempted homicide, aggravated assault and two gun violations. Jurors began deliberating shortly after 5 p.m. and left for the day about 6 p.m. They’ll resume deliberations Wednesday morning.

Brooks said he had been in the area that evening doing work on the car of an acquaintance named Brandon. He got to the apartment complex around 1 p.m. — after he “rose before the sun,” did a half-hour of sun-gazing and an hour of yoga — and started working by 2 p.m.

He had only gotten through replacing the front brakes and rotors when he packed up for the night around 9 p.m.: he said he didn’t want the noise of replacing the back brakes to keep anyone up.

He said he was walking down Stonecliffe Drive toward Monroeville Boulevard wearing his orange vest — he liked to remain visible to passing cars after dark — when he spotted a backpack on the ground in one of the apartment parking lots. He said he picked it up with the intent of pressing apartment intercom buttons to determine who it belonged to.

Advertise with us

At that moment, he said, police pulled up and took him into custody. He maintained to jurors that he wasn’t the one in the vest who had just fired at Sgt. MacDonald, and that investigators manipulated the evidence to fit the case he said they constructed against him.

“I have been prejudiced against,” he said in his half-hour closing argument that, at times, meandered into his love for “all sentient organisms” — even the prosecutors and the members of the jury. “I have been wrongly accused.”

Mr. Zur told jurors he was “begging” them to “please use your common sense.”

“On its face, it’s a bit far-fetched that we all got together with a sole purpose of framing an innocent man.”