It was all so pointless, the judge said.

Jaime Jones is dead. Bryan Perkins-Jiles, of Carrick, is going to prison. All because the latter took offense to a joke Mr. Jones made — a joke about buying a round of energy drinks.

“It’s stupid,” Common Pleas Judge Elliott Howsie said Tuesday ahead of Perkins-Jiles’ sentencing for a 2023 homicide.

“Why are we here?” the judge asked. “Why is another young man dead? Because of some ribbing.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Jones, a 31-year-old father of a young son, had been out with friends at a club early May 26, 2023. Perkins-Jiles, too, was out with friends at the same club. Shortly after last call, around 2 a.m., the two groups saw each other again outside Noble Mart in Swissvale.

Perkins-Jiles had driven to the convenience store. Mr. Jones and his friends walked. When their respective groups spotted each other, Mr. Jones joked that Perkins-Jiles could have given them a ride. Instead, he said, Perkins-Jiles could buy the next round — of Red Bull energy drinks. It was meant to be a joke — they were at a convenience store, after all.

There was no reason to take offense, Judge Howsie said. And when he did take offense, he told Perkins-Jiles, he should have just left.

“Why didn’t he leave? Just leave,” he said. “Just leave and we’re not here.”

He was so close — he was already in the car, the judge said. Upset by the jokes, Perkins-Jiles went and sat briefly in his car as his own group of friends and Mr. Jones’ group went into the convenience store. Instead of leaving, the judge lamented, Perkins-Jiles got out, went inside, and walked through the crowd directly to Mr. Jones.

Advertise with us

The fight spilled outside. Perkins-Jiles testified that he didn’t pull his gun until someone struck him in the head with a bottle. Witnesses said no one hit Perkins-Jiles until they saw him reaching toward his gun.

What was indisputable was that Perkins-Jiles opened fire, killing Mr. Jones and severely wounding Mr. Jones’ friend.

A jury convicted him of third-degree murder in April.

The judge sentenced him to 15 to 30 years in prison for the murder conviction plus 10 to 20 years for the aggravated assault of Mr. Jones’ friend. He will serve them consecutively, for a total of 25 to 50 years in state prison.

“All over a Red Bull,” Judge Howsie said. “All because of someone taking exception over jokes about Red Bull.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Jones’ mother, Lashelle Carter, said her son’s death changed her life in the worst possible ways.

“I can’t sleep. It affected by job. I almost lost my house,” she said. “It changed me. I’m not the happy-go-lucky person I used to be.”

She called it a wound that will never heal, saying there was no real way to describe “the depth of the pain that I carry every day since that moment.”

Ms. Carter said her son had a big future ahead of him, and she lamented the fact that his son was “only able to enjoy his dad for four years of his tiny life.”

“He destroyed a future of memories and left a future of pain,” she said of Perkins-Jiles, then looked up at him from her spot on the witness stand. “I do forgive you because I was brought up in the church.”

Advertise with us

‘You threw it away’

Perkins-Jiles’ sister, Brittney Perkins, said she and her siblings — Bryan, the older brother, and Brandon, her younger brother — had childhoods that started out bright. She said her older brother was intelligent and on track to graduate early. Their father was not in the picture, she said, but their mother made sure they kept up in school and enrolled them in extracurriculars. But they missed some school, and their mother occasionally used drugs — once Children, Youth and Family Services got involved, she said, it all fell apart.

Indeed, the Perkins family was the subject of a 2002 Post-Gazette article that explored the shortcomings and gaps in the CYF system. It described an absentee caseworker who continually failed to follow court orders: to get the children psychological evaluations, to enroll Brittney and Brandon in summer camp, and to help Perkins-Jiles get a summer job.

According to the 2002 story, when the children’s mother enrolled in drug treatment that took her out of the home for several hours each day, the caseworker threatened to take her children out of the home.

Brittney Perkins on Tuesday described moving through several foster homes until Perkins-Jiles was old enough to watch over them.

“He had become responsible for me and my brother,” she told the judge. “His mental health decline started from [when we] were taken out of our home.”

Advertise with us

She described him selling his video games to buy them food.

He was arrested at age 19 on drug and gun charges and sentenced to four to nine years in prison, records show. It’s not clear when he was released, but he was arrested again on more gun charges in 2017. He got involved in a trade school program during that stint in jail, his sister said, and he was doing well for years afterward. He was in the process of buying a house, he had a nice car and “he was doing pretty good,” she said.

That just added to the bitter tragedy of it all, Judge Howsie said: “You had made it, and you threw it all away over a joke about a Red Bull.”

Perkins-Jiles’ attorney, Jacob Todd Naylor, asked the judge to consider his client’s childhood a mitigating factor. Brittney Perkins had the same childhood, Judge Howsie said, and she wasn’t charged with murder. Neither was the youngest of the siblings, Brandon.

When Mr. Naylor pointed to the defendant’s diagnosis of schizoaffective disorder, the judge dismissed it as a factor: There were probably one or two people in the courtroom with the same diagnosis, he said, and they hadn’t murdered anyone.

Advertise with us

He asked Perkins-Jiles, slumped at the defense table, what it was like to grow up without a father.

“[I was] always seeking somebody to be like — a role model in my life,” he said.

Now, the judge said, Perkins-Jiles had foisted that circumstance onto Mr. Jones’ young son.

“He doesn’t know what life is and the deck is already stacked against him,” he said. “It’s stupid.”